Intentional Summary

Chapter 1. The Intention Stack

Overview

At the heart of every action lies an intention, whether we're aware of it or not. This chapter explores how these mental plans shape our days, from automatic responses to conscious choices. It traces where intentions come from, identifying six primary sources: biology, social environment, conditioning, the pursuit of happiness, past lessons, and self-reflection. Often, these sources operate unnoticed, making intentions slippery and habitual.

Much of our behavior runs on autopilot, driven by default intentions that form from conditioning and account for a large portion of daily actions. While efficient, they can keep us in repetitive patterns. To break free and create meaningful change, we need deliberate intentions, which are consciously crafted through self-reflection. This shift is essential for true productivity, enabling focus on high-impact activities.

Understanding intention's structure helps harness its power: each has a source, duration, strength, and depth. Strength balances desire and aversion, while depth connects to core values. These intentions don't exist alone; they nest within a hierarchy called the Intention Stack. From present-moment actions to lifelong values, this stack shows how small steps can align with grand aspirations, providing a blueprint for intentional living.

Our values are the invisible forces steering every intention, infusing actions with meaning and driving internal conflicts. Autonomy allows us to trade off between competing values, making choices that resonate deeply. When control is lost, actions can feel empty, highlighting how values shape our sense of purpose and even color our memories.

Since life often runs on autopilot, noticing default intentions is key. Practices like mindfulness help observe these automatic patterns without judgment, revealing the cues that trigger routines. By slowing down and paying attention, we create space to layer deliberate intentions on top, carving out a more purposeful path.

Unlocking self-reflective capacity is another powerful tool. When stuck, intentionally letting the mind wander—a state called scatterfocus—can spark breakthroughs. During this time, we naturally gravitate toward goals and generate ideas, strengthening our ability to set and pursue intentions. Regular scatterfocus activates this capacity, reducing autopilot living and boosting intentionality.

By weaving these insights together, the chapter illustrates how from understanding intentions' origins to building a personal Intention Stack, we can move from reactive habits to proactive, meaningful actions, setting the stage for a more deliberate life.

The Sources of Intention

The chapter opens by establishing intention as a fundamental driver of all behavior, defining it as a mental plan to do something, whether conscious or automatic. Research indicates that environmental cues can trigger intentions without our awareness, producing outcomes similar to conscious goals.

This leads to an exploration of where intentions originate, framed by a personal anecdote about asking a Buddhist monk this very question. Despite the apparent divide between spirituality and productivity, both fields converge on the study of deliberate action. The monk’s answer, which aligns with scientific research, identifies six primary sources of intention:

• Biology (e.g., seeking a restroom).
• Social Environment (e.g., joining friends after work).
• Conditioning from family or culture (e.g., eating quickly based on childhood routine).
• The Pursuit of Happiness & Avoidance of Pain (e.g., asking someone out to alleviate loneliness).
• Past Lessons (e.g., applying a new communication technique from a workshop).
• Self-Reflective Capacity (e.g., pausing to consider what you truly want from your week).

Personality traits also influence the ambitions of our intentions; for instance, conscientious, self-confident, or competitive individuals tend to set more challenging goals. The section emphasizes that while we set intentions constantly, most slip by unnoticed, making them "slippery." A simple exercise is suggested: try to catch your next intention to stop reading and identify what triggered it—boredom, distraction, an interruption—to illustrate how automatic this process is.

Default vs. Deliberate Intentions

Our nature as happiness-seeking beings leads to conditioned responses, often governed by a "neural autopilot mode." The intentions formed from this conditioning are termed default intentions. They are powerful, driving an estimated 40-45% of our daily actions, and essentially constitute our habits. Habits are default intentions triggered by environmental cues: time, location, preceding events, emotional states, or the presence of certain people.

While efficient and often useful (like a morning coffee routine), default intentions alone are insufficient for meaningful goal attainment. To break from conditioned patterns and create change, we must employ deliberate intentions. These are constructed consciously through our self-reflective capacity—the ability to look inward, take ownership, and choose actions that align with who we want to be, rather than simply reacting.

Deliberate intention is positioned as the core of true productivity, enabling us to work smarter by focusing on high-impact activities (like training an intern) over low-yield ones (a pointless meeting). It allows for course correction and infuses our actions with greater meaning.

The Anatomy and Architecture of Intention

To understand how to harness intention, the chapter outlines its key structural attributes:

1. Source: The six origins listed earlier.
2. Duration: Can span from seconds (taking a sip) to a lifetime (being a generous person).
3. Strength: Defined as Desire minus Aversion. Every task has elements that pull us toward it and push us away. Maximizing desire and minimizing aversion is crucial for follow-through.
4. Depth: How closely the intention is connected to our core values. Deeper connections to what we cherish create stronger motivation. Values are described as our broadest, deepest intentions—the guiding principles of our life.

These individual intentions do not exist in isolation. They are nested within one another in a hierarchical structure called the Intention Stack. At any given moment, your immediate action is supported by a stack of broader intentions.

• The bottom of the stack is your present-moment intention (e.g., dial into a conference call).
• This nests inside a short-term plan (e.g., develop a relationship with a potential partner).
• Which fits into a goal (e.g., secure three new business partnerships).
• Which aligns with a life priority (e.g., expand into new markets).
• All of which are ultimately rooted in your core values (e.g., accomplishment and benevolence).

This nested structure illustrates how our smallest actions can—and ideally should—connect to our largest aspirations. The book promises to later guide the reader in constructing their own Intention Stack by working through these levels: from clarifying values, to setting aligned goals and priorities, down to defining plans and actionable next steps. The following chapter is previewed to delve into the twelve fundamental human values that sit at the heart of this stack.

Values in Action

Our personal values are the invisible forces steering every intention we set. In any given moment, the actions we feel most compelled to take are typically the ones that align with whichever of our values wins out internally. For instance, a value like pleasure might lead to enjoying a celebratory drink, while self-direction could inspire choosing a healthier option. This internal tug-of-war between values—such as tradition versus progress—often explains our strongest personal conflicts and societal debates. When we have autonomy over our time, we can make trade-offs between these competing values, allowing our deepest-held defaults to shape meaningful actions. Conversely, when control is taken away, like with an unexpected work assignment, our actions can feel less meaningful because they aren't expressions of our core values. This link between values and meaning also applies to memories, which we filter through our value system. Ultimately, aligning our goals with our true values is the secret to consistent follow-through, and the Intention Stack is designed to facilitate this alignment.

Noticing Your Defaults

Our default intentions, which operate on autopilot, are fundamentally connected to our values. While autopilot mode is often dismissed, it holds immense power—providing mental rest and freedom from constant decision-making. By noticing these default intentions as they form, we gain insight into the habitual actions that compose much of our daily lives. A practical way to cultivate this awareness is through mindfulness. Though not for everyone, mindfulness training offers profound productivity benefits by sharpening focus and reducing distractions. The practice involves observing small, automatic actions—like feeling each footstep or noticing cues that trigger routines—without judgment. For example, while fetching a snack, one might consciously observe the sequence of intentions that arise, from walking to recycling. This simple act of slowing down and paying attention reveals how fleeting default intentions are, constantly replaced by new ones as environments change. By noticing this default way of being, we lay the groundwork for layering deliberate intentions on top, carving out a more intentional path.

Unlocking Self-Reflective Capacity

When faced with an impasse, deliberately letting the mind wander—a state called scatterfocus—can unlock powerful problem-solving and goal-setting insights. Activities like going for a walk or taking a bath allow the mind to roam freely, often leading to breakthroughs that hours of focused effort might miss. During scatterfocus, our minds naturally gravitate toward our goals and unresolved puzzles. Research shows that when mind-wandering, we spend about 48% of our time thinking about the future, 28% in the present, 12% in the past, and 12% on timeless ideas. Notably, we think about our goals fourteen times more often in this state compared to when we're focused. This process taps into our self-reflective capacity, enabling us to plan, generate ideas, and strengthen intentional action. To reduce autopilot living and boost intentionality, it's crucial to activate this capacity through regular scatterfocus time, whether via walks, creative hobbies, or other reflective practices. This sets the stage for forming smarter, more deliberate intentions.

Key Takeaways

• Values Drive Intentions: Every action is guided by personal values, and internal value conflicts shape our decisions and sense of meaning.
• Autonomy Enhances Meaning: Having control over our time allows us to act in alignment with our values, making experiences more meaningful.
• Mindfulness Reveals Defaults: Practicing mindfulness helps observe automatic intentions, providing insight into habitual behaviors and creating space for deliberate choice.
• Scatterfocus Fuels Goals: Intentional mind-wandering (scatterfocus) significantly increases goal-related thinking and problem-solving, leveraging our self-reflective capacity.
• Layer Intentionality: Our default intentions form a baseline way of living; deliberate intentions are layered on top to craft a more purposeful path.

Download Mindmap

If you like this summary, you probably also like these summaries...

Atomic Habits

by James Clear

The Psychology of Money

by Morgan Housel

Deep Work

by Cal Newport

Intentional Summary

Chapter 2. Values

Overview

At its heart, this chapter explores how our values—those deep-seated, long-term intentions that feel closest to our ideal self—serve as the ultimate source of motivation for everything we do. These guiding principles differ from personality; we usually accept and cherish them. They connect directly to our goals through a model called the Intention Stack, which visually links our broadest values down to the specific actions we take today, showing that a goal is most powerful when it’s anchored to a core value. Between values and goals sit priorities, which act as bridges. While there are universal values, our personal list of priorities is endless and highly personal.

Our unique hierarchy of values is shaped by two key polarities: whether we lean toward Openness to Change or Conservation, and whether our focus is on Self-Enhancement or Self-Transcendence. These orientations determine the strength of twelve fundamental human motivations, including Self-Direction, Achievement, Benevolence, and Security. These values don’t exist in a vacuum; they relate to each other in a dynamic, circular model—similar values support each other, while opposing ones, like Tradition and Self-Direction, create natural tension. This structure is nearly universal.

We inherit the seeds of our values from genetics and our early social environment, primarily through our parents, but we actively refine this hierarchy through self-reflection and choice. Over time, our deliberate actions can reshape our default habits, effectively changing the values we live by. These values are powerful predictors of our behavior, influencing everything from our career choices and religious beliefs to our daily habits and social attitudes. For example, valuing Benevolence makes one more likely to volunteer, while high Universalism is linked to greater tolerance.

While our value hierarchy is generally stable, being built on years of conditioning, it can evolve. Major life changes, like immigrating to a new country, can gradually shift our priorities to align with a new environment. To understand your own motivational core, you can either reflectively rank a list of core values or take a formal assessment like the Revised Portrait Value Questionnaire (PVQ-RR). Seeing your hierarchy in black and white can be revealing—as the author finds when his own top values of Self-Direction and Hedonism explain his love for autonomy and sensory pleasure, while his low scores in Power and Tradition clarify his aversion to dominance and rigid customs.

This self-knowledge redefines success. It’s not about external trophies but about alignment. A personally meaningful goal is one that satisfies multiple core values at once. This principle extends to our relationships and conflicts with others. Many heated disagreements, whether about immigration or climate policy, are ultimately clashes of underlying values—like Universalism versus Security. Recognizing this can foster empathy, allowing us to connect with the person even when we disagree with their position. Ultimately, living in harmony with your values is the truest form of success, providing an internal yardstick for a fulfilling life.

Defining Our Foundational Values

The chapter begins by establishing that values represent our deepest, longest-term intentions—they are the "true nature" that underlies everything we do. Unlike personality traits, which we might want to change, we see our values as being closer to our ideal self. They are broad, trans-situational (applying across all life contexts), desirable, and serve as our guiding principles. Critically, values and goals are intimately connected; values are essentially the ultimate, lifelong goals we are pursuing. Every action we take is propelled by one or more underlying values.

The Motivational Hierarchy and Intention Stack

Our personal hierarchy of values determines what motivates us most powerfully. This hierarchy fits into a larger framework called the Intention Stack. This model visually connects our deepest values to our daily actions:

• Values sit at the top as our broadest, lifelong intentions.
• Priorities (or subvalues) stem from our values.
• Goals are specific targets that fit inside our priorities.
• Plans are the strategies to achieve those goals.
• Present Intention is the actionable step we take today.

A goal is only fully defined and maximally motivating when it is connected both to our daily actions (the bottom of the stack) and our core values (the top of the stack). This alignment makes progress both tangible and deeply meaningful.

Priorities: The Bridge Between Values and Goals

Priorities are the subvalues that act as a container for our goals. While there is a fixed set of fundamental values, the number of potential priorities is endless. For example, the broad value of Benevolence can include priorities like being helpful, honest, or loyal. The value of Achievement can contain priorities like being successful, capable, or ambitious. Some priorities, like health, can be subjective and may connect to different core values (e.g., Security, Hedonism, or Achievement) for different people. We connect with our priorities by continually editing and aligning our goals with what we value most.

The Four Orientations That Shape Our Values

Our specific value hierarchy is shaped by where we fall on two fundamental polarities:

1. Openness to Change vs. Conservation: Do you prefer things to improve and change, or remain stable and predictable?
2. Self-Enhancement vs. Self-Transcendence: Is your focus primarily on enriching yourself or on enriching others?

These orientations determine which of the twelve fundamental values, first identified by researcher Shalom Schwartz, will be strongest for us. The values are:

• Self-Direction: Independence of thought and action.
• Stulation: Need for novelty and excitement.
• Hedonism: Pursuit of pleasure and enjoyment.
• Achievement: Pursuit of success and competence.
• Power: Control over people and resources.
• Face: Preservation of public image and avoidance of humiliation.
• Security: Desire for safety and stability.
• Tradition: Respect for customs and rituals.
• Conformity: Adherence to rules and social expectations.
• Humility: Recognizing one's place in the larger world.
• Universalism: Concern for the welfare of all people and nature.
• Benevolence: Caring for the welfare of close others.

A few values, like Hedonism and Humility, straddle the lines between these orientations.

The Relativity of Values and the "Values Pie"

Values don't exist in isolation; they have dynamic relationships with each other. Schwartz's research models them in a circular "pie chart" where:

• Similar values are located close together (e.g., Achievement and Power).
• Opposing values are located across from each other (e.g., Tradition vs. Self-Direction, Security vs. Benevolence).

This structure has been validated across over 80 countries and is considered a universal organization of human motivation. Furthermore, the original twelve values can be broken down into nineteen more granular top-level values (e.g., Self-Direction divides into Self-Directed Thought and Self-Directed Action; Universalism divides into Tolerance, Societal Concern, and Protecting Nature).

The Origins of Our Values

Our values are built from the same foundation as our default intentions: a combination of genetics and social environment. The primary source is our parents and caregivers, who transmit values both directly through instruction and indirectly through modeling. However, we are not passive recipients. Our capacity for self-reflection allows us to actively choose which perceived values to adopt or reject, shaping our own hierarchy. Over time, our deliberate intentions and repeated actions can solidify into new default habits, effectively reshaping our character and the values we live by.

The Connection Between Values and Behavior

Our values are powerful predictors of our actions and beliefs. For instance, research shows clear links between specific values and religiosity. People who are religious tend to place a high importance on tradition, conformity, and security, while valuing pleasure, self-direction, and stimulation less. This pattern, observed across multiple cultures, makes sense given that a primary function of religion is to temper self-indulgence.

Career paths are also deeply intertwined with our values. Someone who prioritizes benevolence and universalism might gravitate toward psychology or social work, while a person who values security and conformity may find fulfillment as a secretary or accountant. Those with strong achievement and power values are more likely to become managers or financial advisers. While it's hard to say whether values shape the career or the career reinforces the values, alignment between the two leads to greater job satisfaction. This principle extends beyond work: the more our everyday actions align with our values, the more meaningful and motivating they feel.

Specific values predict specific behaviors. Valuing benevolence makes one more likely to volunteer and donate to charity. Valuing universalism is linked to greater tolerance toward minority groups. Our actions, from our careers to our daily choices, are outward expressions of our internal value system.

The Stability and Evolution of Our Values

Our individual values are remarkably stable over time. Because they are built from a foundation of deeply conditioned default intentions, changing a core value is difficult—it requires undoing or significantly counterbalancing years of conditioning.

However, values can and do shift, particularly when we are thrust into new environments that demand adaptation. Immigrants, for example, often experience a gradual shift in their values to align more closely with those of their new country. Studies of people moving from Russia to Finland showed an increase in universalism and security values, while those moving from Poland to the UK saw their values for self-direction and power shift. These changes continue to evolve the longer they settle in. This demonstrates that while our values are stable, they are not set in stone; significant life changes can reshape them over a long period.

Uncovering Your Personal Values

There are two practical ways to identify your strongest values. The first is an intuitive, reflective exercise. By slowly reviewing a list of the twelve basic values with their definitions, you can rank them from most to least important. Your top values will feel instinctive and non-negotiable. A helpful clue is to examine how you actually spend your time and resources, as your daily life reflects the values you engage with most.

For a more scientific and granular assessment, you can take a formal values test. The author recommends the Revised Portrait Value Questionnaire (PVQ-RR), which is based on the most validated psychological model. A licensed version is available on the book's website for a small fee. Whether through reflection or a formal test, connecting with your core values is an exercise in understanding the truest articulation of who you are.

A Personal Case Study: The Author’s Own Values

To ground the theory in reality, the author shares his own value hierarchy, as revealed by the PVQ-RR test. His strongest values are:

1. Self-direction (by a wide margin)
2. Pleasure/Hedonism
3. Humility

His weakest values are Power and Tradition, with Stimulation also quite low. This hierarchy makes immediate sense to him. It explains his intense need for autonomy, his deep appreciation for sensory experiences (like memorable meals or relaxing baths), and his aversion to dominance or competition. It also clarifies why he prefers calm pleasures over highly stimulating environments.

Comparing values with a close partner can be illuminating. The author and his wife share high universalism and self-direction values, which explains their mutual interest in helping others and independent work. However, she values stimulation much more highly, which helps them understand and negotiate their different preferences for social planning and travel, allowing them to find a satisfying middle ground.

Redefining Success Through Values

The chapter concludes by redefining success not as the achievement of external milestones, but as living in alignment with your personal values. The author illustrates this with a personal story: after training for a marathon, he chose not to run the final race. To someone with high achievement values, this seems baffling. But for him, the meaningful part was the self-directed process of learning and the hedonistic pleasure of running itself. His values of self-direction and pleasure were fulfilled, so he felt successful and satisfied without the traditional trophy.

This reframes goal-setting entirely. The most motivating and meaningful goals are those that fuel multiple core values simultaneously. For example, a person who values both achievement and universalism might find profound success in building a charity that helps people on a large scale. Chasing productivity or goals for their own sake often leads to hollow outcomes. True success and fulfillment come from ensuring your plans and actions are authentic expressions of what you value most, allowing you to feel successful by your own internal yardstick.

Key Takeaways

• Our values reliably predict a wide range of our behaviors, from religious affiliation and career choice to daily habits and social attitudes.
• While values are generally stable over a lifetime, they can gradually evolve in response to major environmental changes, such as moving to a new country.
• You can identify your core values through reflective ranking or by taking a scientifically validated test like the PVQ-RR.
• Understanding your own value hierarchy—and that of people close to you—provides powerful insight into your motivations, preferences, and relationships.
• True success is redefined as living in alignment with your values. The most meaningful and motivating goals are those that satisfy multiple core values at once, not those that pursue external validation alone.

This portion of the chapter examines how our core values are often the hidden engine behind our most passionate disagreements and conflicts with others. When we encounter a viewpoint we strongly oppose, it’s rarely just about surface-level facts; it’s typically an expression of a deeper, competing value system.

The text provides two potent examples. Disagreements over immigration can frequently be traced to a fundamental clash between the value of universalism—concern for the welfare of all people—and the values of security and tradition, which prioritize protecting the existing social order and cultural identity. Similarly, debates about climate change often reflect a tension between universalism (protecting the planet for everyone) and power—specifically economic power and the control over resources and industries.

The author’s key insight is that recognizing this dynamic is a powerful tool for constructive engagement. By attempting to identify the underlying values driving an opposing viewpoint, we can better understand the person’s perspective on a human level. This doesn’t require agreeing with their conclusion, but it allows for empathy. Seeing the values “behind the scenes” makes it easier to comprehend their motivations and connect with them as individuals, even when their specific opinions feel personally challenging to accept.

Key Takeaways

• Values Drive Disagreement: Many heated conflicts, from political debates to personal arguments, are at their core a clash of underlying values, not just opinions.
• Examples in Action: Issues like immigration often pit universalism against security/tradition, while climate change debates can frame universalism against power and economic control.
• Empathy Through Understanding: Identifying the values behind someone’s position fosters empathy, making it possible to connect with their humanity even when you strongly disagree with their conclusions.

Download Mindmap

Intentional Summary

Chapter 3. Goal Editing

Overview

This chapter starts by questioning a popular productivity staple: SMART goals. While widely used, this framework’s origins aren’t scientific, and research suggests it can be counterproductive, often prioritizing achievable and realistic targets over more motivating, challenging ones. The real issue with traditional goals is about control. We can control our actions, but not outcomes, so every goal is just a prediction—one that life’s complexities often disrupt. This mismatch leads to frustration, especially given our finite daily resource of roughly four focused hours.

Instead of complex systems, effective goal-setting hinges on three simple, interconnected parts. First, an outcome goal is your predicted result, providing motivation. Second, a process goal is the actionable habit you can control, which actually drives progress. Third is your rate of progress—the realistic timeline and energy you can dedicate. These elements form a dynamic system where outcome and process goals work together.

However, goals compete for the same limited resources: time, energy, and attention. The strategy of "picking favorites" is crucial here, allowing you to intentionally scale process goals up or down based on your current capacity. Your progress is also shaped by the psychological forces of desire and aversion. Managing aversion often means shortening the timeframe for a process goal to make it feel more tangible.

You can visualize these motivational shifts over time by sketching a desire curve for a goal, helping you anticipate and plan for dips in enthusiasm. To get a clear picture of everything you're working toward, you create a Goal Inventory, listing every goal and defining its three components. This external view sets the stage for the essential work of editing.

Editing goals is an art. You might discover sepia-toned goals—idealized fantasies that clash with daily reality—or spot values misalignments where a goal’s framing doesn’t resonate with what truly matters to you. Reframing it can unlock motivation. A powerful tool for this is mental contrasting, where you vividly imagine success and then immediately identify the real-world obstacles, allowing you to create new process goals to overcome them.

All these concepts come together in a practical Goal Review Ritual, a regular practice of reviewing your inventory, updating your goals, and planning specific follow-through actions. This ritual turns goal-setting into a dynamic, living process. Finally, the chapter reframes quitting as a strategic skill. Dropping a goal is not failure but a conscious decision to reallocate your finite resources toward aims that are better aligned, embracing the uncertainty inherent in figuring out what truly matters.

Beyond SMART Goals

The chapter opens by challenging a ubiquitous productivity concept: SMART goals. While the acronym—Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, Time-bound—is catchy and feels practical, its origin is not scientific. It emerged from a 1981 business magazine article designed for "management excellence," not from psychological research on goal attainment.

Research indicates this model can be counterproductive. It often contradicts established findings, such as the benefit of setting challenging, difficult goals (SMART emphasizes Achievable and Realistic). Furthermore, goals don't always need to be highly specific to be effective, especially during the learning phase of a new skill. The criteria are also redundant (e.g., Measurable and Specific are similar, as are Achievable and Realistic). While defining any goal is better than nothing, the SMART framework is a weak tool that can lead to less progress and even research waste in academic settings.

The Reason You're Not Following Through

The author shares a personal aversion to big, traditional, outcome-based goals. The core issue is control: we can control our efforts and actions (inputs), but we cannot control outcomes. Therefore, every goal is ultimately a prediction—a guess about where our current and planned actions will lead.

Life's inherent complexity means these predictions will often be wrong. Unforeseen events disrupt our plans, and tasks almost always take longer than we expect. This disconnect between prediction and reality breeds frustration and impatience. Focusing too rigidly on a predicted outcome can also blind us to more meaningful opportunities that arise.

A key constraint in this process is our finite daily focus. Most people have about four focused hours each workday for demanding cognitive tasks. Exceeding this limit compromises sustainable productivity. The solution is to invest our energy primarily in the inputs—the actions we can control—while viewing goals as flexible predictions, not rigid expectations.

Structuring Good Goals

Effective goal-setting is simpler than the SMART model suggests and revolves around three interconnected components:

1. The Outcome Goal: This is the predicted result of your efforts (e.g., save for a house down payment). While outcomes aren't fully controllable, they provide essential motivation and connect daily actions to a larger purpose.
2. The Process Goal: This is the actionable plan or habit that drives progress (e.g., save 5% of each paycheck). Process goals are about the steps you take, focusing your energy on what you can directly influence.
3. The Rate of Progress: This is the timeline and resource allocation for your goal (e.g., achieve the down payment in three years). It involves estimating how much time, attention, and energy you can consistently devote.

Outcome and process goals are two sides of the same coin. Research shows process goals boost motivation to act, while outcome goals lead to better overall results. Each outcome goal should have a corresponding process goal. The initial motivation for a new goal is best spent on planning (sharpening the axe)—around a 20% planning to 80% action ratio—to lock in commitment and create an effective strategy.

Process goals should be refined through experimentation to find the most effective and enjoyable methods. In rare cases, an experience goal (like daily meditation) may blend the process and outcome into one.

When setting your rate of progress, start with a rough estimate of weekly time you can dedicate (e.g., five hours). The key is to be flexible; your capacity and a goal's demands will naturally fluctuate. The system must accommodate life's inevitable spikes and dips in available resources and energy.

Managing Limited Resources and Competing Goals

Our goals don't exist in a vacuum; they compete for the same finite pool of resources like time, energy, and attention. A new lunchtime gym routine might directly cut into your writing time, or a draining morning might leave you with only enough bandwidth for a workout, not creative work. Because we often fail to account for these fluctuations, we end up dropping goals out of overwhelm, not desire. The key is intentionality: recognizing that while you can do anything, you cannot do everything at once.

This leads to the strategy of "picking favorites." When resources are tight—during a busy work period or a family illness—you can calibrate your goals downward by making your process goals less ambitious. Conversely, you can ramp them up when you have more capacity. This isn't failure; it's smart productivity, working with your constraints rather than against them.

The Role of Desire and Aversion

Beyond tangible resources, our progress is heavily influenced by the fluctuating forces of desire (the pull to do something) and aversion (the resistance to it). Every goal contains some degree of aversion—if it didn't, you'd have already achieved it. The more aversive a task feels, the more mental resources it consumes and the less you'll want to do it.

To manage this, align your process goals with your level of aversion. For a highly aversive task, set a shorter-duration process goal. Instead of committing to writing 250 words every day this year, you might schedule three focused sessions per week this month. Shorter timelines make goals feel more tangible and manageable, taming aversion before it derails you.

Mapping Motivation with Desire Curves

Your motivation isn't static. It ebbs and flows across a goal's timeline, creating a "desire curve"—a sketch of how your overall desire (desire minus aversion) is likely to fluctuate.

• The "Polar Dip": Desire stays high until the moment of action, when aversion spikes dramatically.
• Learning a Language: Desire might spike at the start (booking a trip) and near the deadline, but dip in the middle when lessons become tedious.
• Planning a Wedding: Desire might remain consistently high throughout.
• Decluttering a Home: Aversion might be high the entire way.

While you don't need to chart every goal, sketching a desire curve for challenging intentions helps you anticipate motivational dips and plan for them. It allows you to strategically channel energy, perhaps spending more time on planning at the outset when motivation is high, to build momentum for the tougher phases.

Conducting a Goal Inventory

We rarely see all our active goals in one place. A Goal Inventory fixes this. Start by brain-dumping every goal, large and small, onto a list. Then, refine each entry by defining its three components, nesting them according to the Intention Stack:

1. Outcome Goal: The broader "what" you want (e.g., "Build a peaceful mind").
2. Process Goal: The specific "how" (e.g., "Meditate for 20 minutes every morning at 8:05").
3. Rate of Progress/Pace: The speed or intensity (e.g., "Fast and steady").

Group related outcome goals (like Health, Work, Creativity) and list all associated process goals beneath them. This externalized view is crucial for the next step: intelligent editing.

The Art of Editing and Revising Goals

Your first draft of a goal is rarely perfect. Goal attainment is an iterative process of experimentation and refinement. As you review your inventory, you may find some goals feel "off." Struggle isn't always a bad sign—meaningful goals are hard—but it's vital to examine its source.

• Sepia-Toned Goals: These are idealized fantasies (like becoming a 5:30 a.m. riser) where we romanticize the outcome but gloss over the daily reality. The fantasy provides a false sense of accomplishment, seducing us into enjoying the future now without inducing action. The collision of this sepia-toned ideal with gritty reality often reveals the goal is a poor fit for our actual biology, interests, and life.

• Values Misalignments: Sometimes struggle stems from a goal being framed in a way that clashes with your core values. A goal to "get a six-pack for beach season" appeals to the value of appearance ("face"), but if you truly value health or self-direction, it won't motivate you. Reframing the same essential outcome (e.g., eating healthier) to align with your true values ("experiment with nutrition for self-knowledge" or "fuel my body for longevity") can make the same actions feel effortless and enjoyable.

Obliterating Obstacles with Mental Contrasting

A powerful editing and maintenance tactic is mental contrasting. For a chosen goal:

1. Visualize Success: Vividly imagine the positive future of achieving it.
2. Identify Obstacles: Immediately contrast that by realistically imagining the key obstacles that will stand in your way (e.g., wanting to watch TV instead of write, or the cost of social events when saving money).

This technique moves beyond unhelpful daydreaming by forcing you to confront the gap between your present and your desired future. The most powerful application is to then define a new process goal specifically targeted at obliterating that primary obstacle, thereby accelerating your progress.

The Goal Review Ritual

The chapter introduces a powerful, practical ritual for regularly revising your goals, bringing together the concepts of outcome/process goals, rates of progress, sepia-toned fantasies, and value alignment. This "goal review" consists of three straightforward steps conducted on a regular cadence, ideally weekly.

Review Your Current Inventory Begin by examining your complete list of outcomes, processes, and rates of progress. This simple act of review brings all active intentions to the forefront of your mind, priming you for evaluation. During this stage, you might notice goals that have stagnated, rates of progress that seem inaccurate, or the need to create space for new ambitions.

Update and Edit Your Goals This is the core editing phase. Scrutinize your list and make necessary changes:

• Process Goals: You may need to edit these, often by "lowering them in the Intention Stack" to make them cover a shorter timeframe, thus reducing aversion and increasing tangibility.
• Outcome Goals: Adjust these based on where your current processes are actually leading you, or to better align with your evolving desired destination and core values.
• Recognize Misfires: Identify goals that are actually sepia-toned fantasies or fundamentally misaligned with your values—a realization that can be humorous in hindsight—and edit them to better serve you.
• Rates of Progress: Update the pace (e.g., slow, medium, fast) for each goal. For maintenance goals, note how steadily you're conserving past progress. A consistently low rate of progress for a high-priority goal is a signal to experiment with new or more intense processes.

Plan Your Follow-Through For the period until your next review (e.g., the coming week), plan specific actions to advance your process goals. This includes:

• Scheduling dedicated time blocks.
• Using mental contrasting to preemptively identify obstacles.
• Setting up reminders and calendar events.
• Enlisting social support by asking a friend to join you.
• Realistically accounting for your available time, attention, and energy to adjust ambitions accordingly.

The simplicity of this ritual is its strength, transforming goal-setting from a static activity into a dynamic practice of consistent review and deliberate action.

The Strategic Art of Dropping Goals

A critical but often overlooked aspect of goal editing is the deliberate abandonment of goals. This is framed not as failure, but as a strategic opportunity to reallocate finite resources—time, energy, and attention—and to try other goals that might be a better fit.

A goal becomes a prime candidate for dropping when it proves fundamentally incompatible with your core values, and efforts to reframe it within another value have failed. For example, a goal of "living off the grid to reduce carbon footprint" might be perpetually unmotivating for someone who deeply values achievement and power within a corporate structure; dropping it could free resources for a more aligned goal, like leading a corporate clean-energy initiative.

Every goal pursued carries an opportunity cost—the other goals you are inherently saying "no" to. Embracing the uncertainty of not knowing which goals are ultimately "right" is part of the process. Regular review creates the space to identify goals that are no longer serving you, allowing you to curate a set of intentions that are truly resonant and actionable.

Key Takeaways

• Implement a regular Goal Review Ritual (Review, Update, Plan) to systematically edit your goals, ensuring they remain aligned with your progress, values, and available resources.
• Editing is multi-faceted: It can involve adjusting the timeframe of a process goal, refining an outcome based on real-world results, or updating your assessed rate of progress.
• Dropping a goal is a strategic choice, not a failure. It frees your limited resources (time, energy, attention) to pursue opportunities that are better aligned with your values.
• Embrace uncertainty in the goal-setting process; you won't always know in advance which goals will fit best, and regular review is the tool for discovering this.
• Goal attainment is inherently messy—life's complexities will steer you off course. Consistent review and revision are the navigation tools that keep you moving toward your ambitions, even when the path isn't straight.

Download Mindmap

If you like this summary, you probably also like these summaries...

Atomic Habits

by James Clear

The Psychology of Money

by Morgan Housel

Deep Work

by Cal Newport

Intentional Summary

Chapter 4. Ugly Goals: Lowering Aversion

Overview

This chapter tackles the stubborn gap between our intentions and our actions, identifying procrastination not as a failure of discipline but as an emotion-regulation problem. We avoid tasks because, in the moment, they feel bad. This aversion stems from six key characteristics: a task might be boring, unpleasant, frustrating, far off in the future, unstructured, or feel meaningless. To overcome this, the logical planning from earlier chapters—like values editing and process goals—provides essential ammunition for the brain’s logical centers to win the battle against emotional impulse.

The strategies presented are a toolkit for lowering aversion by directly countering these characteristics. To fight boredom, you can reverse it by making the goal more challenging, turning tedium into an engaging test. For unpleasant tasks, tactics like aversion journaling, task pairing with something enjoyable, or reframing the goal to benefit others can inject needed enjoyment. Frustration often signals you’re focused on the wrong type of goal; shifting from a performance goal orientation (proving ability) to a learning goal orientation (developing competence) cultivates a growth mindset and reduces anxiety.

For goals that feel too distant, you bridge the time gap by making them feel immediate. This can be done by defining a target pace with a visual progress chart or by breaking the large goal into near-future milestones with built-in rewards. Since willpower is unreliable, you engineer success through structure. This means planning your process when motivation is high, using habit stacking to connect new goals to existing routines, and building in rewards and penalties like a Habit Points system to make follow-through easier. For the most aversive daily tasks, implementation intentions—specific "if-then" plans—create automaticity and drastically increase follow-through.

Ultimately, this work is grounded in aligning goals with your core values, which transforms them from chores into meaningful pursuits and directly counters feelings of meaninglessness. The chapter concludes by reframing aversion as an invitation—a useful signal to diagnose what’s wrong with your approach and apply the right strategy, turning procrastination from a hindrance into a tool for crafting more engaging and sustainable goals.

The Intention Gap and Its Emotional Roots

Even with clear outcome and process goals in place, a persistent gap often remains between our intentions and our actual actions. This "intention gap" can widen into a chasm when a goal becomes aversive over time, leading to procrastination. The chapter frames procrastination not as a simple failure of willpower or time management, but as an emotion-regulation problem. It's an irrational, hardwired human impulse to avoid negative feelings associated with a task.

Procrastination as an Emotional Impulse

The decision to act or delay is a neurological battle between two competing brain pathways:

• The logical pathway involves the hippocampus and caudate nucleus, which help us imagine future rewards and value, pushing us toward action.
• The emotional pathway links the amygdala and insula, generating negative emotions (aversion) that repel us from a task.

Procrastination is essentially "giving in to feeling good" in the short term by avoiding the unpleasant task. While personality traits like high impulsiveness make one more prone to delay, and high conscientiousness makes one less so, the tendency to procrastinate is universal and chronic for a significant portion of the population.

The Six Characteristics of Aversion

A task becomes aversive and triggers procrastination when it possesses one or more of these traits:

1. Boring
2. Unpleasant
3. Frustrating
4. Far off in the future
5. Unstructured
6. Meaningless

Situational factors like resentment, a lack of control, and a short deadline can intensify these feelings. The classic example of filing taxes hits nearly all these triggers for most people.

Activating Logic to Lower Aversion

The good news is that the logical planning we've already done—values editing, defining outcomes, setting process goals, and regular reviews—directly counteracts aversion by making goals more meaningful, structured, and tangible. This cognitive-behavioral approach gives the logical centers of the brain the "oxygen" needed to win the battle against emotional impulse, substantially reducing procrastination.

Reversing Boredom with Challenge

A primary strategy for combating the boredom characteristic is to make the goal more challenging. Counterintuitively, increasing the difficulty of a boring task can make it more interesting and engaging, thereby reducing aversion. This isn't about creating "stretch" or improbable goals, but about adding a layer of challenge that transforms tedium into a game or a test of skill.

• Example: Turn washing a mountain of dishes into a timed challenge or a reflective exercise.
• Principle: Challenging goals are more motivating and lead to greater action and self-satisfaction upon completion than easy or moderate goals.

Upping Enjoyment Through Reframing

For tasks that are unpleasant, we can inject enjoyment by altering our approach:

• Aversion Journaling: When resistance hits, pause to write down what you're about to do and why it feels aversive. This act of reflection is less aversive than the task itself and helps deconstruct the negative emotions, often revealing ways to reframe the work.
• Make It About Others: Shift the focus of a self-oriented goal to include how it benefits others (e.g., from "exercise to stay healthy" to "exercise to set a good example for my kids"). This taps into values like benevolence for greater inspiration.
• Task Pairing: Deliberately pair a mindless, unpleasant task with an enjoyable one (e.g., listen to a favorite podcast only while at the gym, or allow social media time as a reward for minutes spent on the aversive task).
• Give Yourself a (False) Choice: Pit two aversive tasks against each other. Choosing between cleaning the garage or the basement closet creates an illusion of control while ensuring you tackle something productive.
• Gamify It: Use apps, devices, or self-imposed rules to turn progress into a game with points, levels, or compelling narratives (like outrunning zombies on a run).

Lowering Frustration by Choosing the Right Goal Type

Frustration often signals you may be working on the wrong type of goal. The chapter introduces a critical distinction:

• Learning Goals: Focus on developing knowledge, skills, or competence.
• Performance Goals: Focus on doing well relative to others or to your own expectations.

This sets the stage for understanding how aligning your goal type with the task can reduce the frustration that fuels aversion.

Shifting Your Focus: From Performance to Learning

When frustration arises from a goal, the issue may not be the goal itself, but the frame through which you view it. Individuals tend toward either a performance goal orientation (focused on proving ability and achieving outcomes for external validation) or a learning goal orientation (focused on developing competence and mastering a process).

Adopting a learning goal orientation is a powerful tool for lowering aversion. It involves embracing a growth mindset—the belief that abilities can be developed through effort. This mindset reframes challenges and setbacks as valuable parts of the learning process rather than threats to your self-worth. Consequently, you experience less frustration and anxiety, and you persist longer.

You can transform a frustrating performance goal into a learning goal by shifting the focus from a rigid outcome to the development of a skill or system. The actions may be identical, but your relationship to the goal changes dramatically.

Bridging the Time Gap: Making Distant Goals Feel Immediate

We naturally discount the importance of distant future goals, feeling less aversion but also less motivation to act on them now. This "time-discounting" is a primary driver of procrastination. We mistakenly believe our future selves will be more motivated, but research shows our motivation and aversion levels remain relatively constant over time.

To combat this, you must make long-term goals more salient in the present. Two effective strategies are:

Define a Target Pace For cumulative, measurable goals (like writing, saving, or training), create a simple chart comparing your actual progress to a linear "pace line" that leads to your completion date.

1. Pick a meaningful, realistic deadline.
2. Create a two-line chart: one for your ideal weekly pace, one for your actual progress.
3. Regularly update and review the chart. This visual tool creates immediate accountability and shows if you're on track or falling behind, making the distant deadline feel tangibly connected to today's actions.

Set Milestones for the Near Future Break a large, distant outcome goal into smaller, shorter-term outcome or process goals. Nest these within your original goal to create a series of tangible, immediate targets. Pair these milestones with rewards and add social accountability to further reinforce progress and bring the goal's benefits into the present.

Engineering Success Through Structure

When willpower fades, structure sustains progress. The key is to design systems that make following through easier than avoiding the goal.

Plan When Motivation is High Invest time upfront, during your motivated phase, to research and design the optimal process goals for your desired outcome. This planning locks in a path forward for when your motivation inevitably dips.

Connect New Goals to Existing Habits Use "habit stacking" to attach a new, aversive intention to an established routine. By anchoring the new behavior to a reliable habit cue (e.g., "after I brush my teeth, I will floss"), you drastically lower the mental energy required to get started.

Incorporate Rewards and Penalties Amplify structure by building in consequences. The "Habit Points" system is one effective method:

• Award yourself points for completing positive process goals (e.g., gym visit = 2 points).
• Redeem points for desired indulgences (e.g., a takeout meal = 25 points). This system reframes vices as earned rewards, makes positive habits more attractive, and auto-regulates your behavior.

The Power of Specificity: Implementation Intentions

For your most aversive and challenging daily intentions, vague plans fail. Implementation intentions are specific "if-then" plans that link a situational cue to a predetermined action.

To create one, define the when, where, and how of your intention. For example: "IF my afternoon work break ends at 3:05 PM, THEN I will immediately put on my running shoes and go for a 20-minute jog." This technique creates a strong mental link between a trigger and your goal-directed response, making action automatic and bypassing the need for conscious decision-making in the moment. The upfront planning effort pays off in vastly higher follow-through rates for tasks you'd rather avoid.

Key Takeaways

• Reframe frustrating performance goals as learning goals to cultivate a growth mindset, reduce anxiety, and increase persistence.
• Combat procrastination on long-term goals by making them feel immediate through target pace tracking and near-future milestones.
• Don’t rely on willpower; build external structure through upfront planning, habit stacking, and reward systems like Habit Points.
• For the most aversive tasks, use ultra-specific implementation intentions ("if-then" plans) to make action automatic.

Aligning Goals with Values

Editing your goals to better reflect your core values transforms them from mundane tasks into meaningful pursuits. This alignment not only boosts enjoyment but also directly counters the procrastination trigger of feeling that a task is meaningless. Even when a goal seems inherently aversive—like enduring a final year at a job before retirement—it’s possible to reframe it. For instance, if you value benevolence, you might shift your focus to mentoring colleagues. If self-direction is key, you could seek out projects that allow autonomy or optimize your workflows. The process is iterative; as you continually adjust your goals to mirror your values, they begin to feel natural and integral to your identity, significantly lowering the aversion that leads to procrastination.

Aversion as an Invitation

Aversion isn't just a barrier—it's a signal inviting you to investigate and refine your approach to goals. When procrastination strikes, use it as a cue to diagnose why a goal feels aversive. Is it too boring, unstructured, or lacking challenge? From there, you can apply targeted strategies: add structure, reframe it as a learning goal, inject enjoyment, increase the difficulty, or journal to reconnect with deeper motivations. The author challenges you to select one or two strategies for your most aversive goals. Over time, as you habitually counterbalance aversion, following through becomes more effortless, saving energy and enhancing progress. This proactive shift turns aversion from a hindrance into a tool for growth.

Key Takeaways

• Aligning goals with your personal values infuses them with meaning, making them more enjoyable and reducing procrastination.
• Even seemingly meaningless tasks can be reframed to connect with your values, such as by focusing on benevolence or self-direction.
• View aversion as a helpful cue to identify and address specific issues with a goal, whether it's lack of structure, challenge, or enjoyment.
• Experiment with strategies like goal reframing, adding fun, or journaling to counteract aversion and build momentum.
• Consistently applying these techniques transforms aversive goals into manageable, even rewarding, parts of your journey.

Download Mindmap

If you like this summary, you probably also like these summaries...

Atomic Habits

by James Clear

The Psychology of Money

by Morgan Housel

Deep Work

by Cal Newport