Cancel Me If You Can

Chapter 1: Chapter 1: The Beginning

Overview

From the very first sentence, Dave Portnoy makes it clear: he never wanted a boss. The urge to work for himself wasn’t some grandiose vision of empire — it was simply the desire to avoid waking up dreading the day. The only things he cared about were sports and gambling, and the traditional job market wasn’t exactly rolling out the red carpet for someone like him. So he built his own door.

The name Barstool Sports came from the most practical of origins: it was the first available URL he liked. The concept was straightforward — a publication that captured what guys actually talk about when they’re at a bar watching a game, in direct opposition to the bitter, joyless sports media in Boston at the time. Reporters like Dan Shaughnessy and Ron Borges seemed to root against the local teams, so Portnoy wanted something fan-first. The inaugural issue’s opening line said it all: “Welcome to the world of Barstool Sports, the only newspaper in Boston written by the common man, for the common man.”

The First Newspaper and Immediate Hurdles

Launching issue #1 was a crash course in getting punched in the mouth by reality. A meeting with the printer, Gannett Publishing, revealed two brutal truths. First, the intricate logo Portnoy had a friend draw was too detailed for newspaper ink — it would turn into a blurry mess. With only 48 hours until print, he had to scramble for a minimalist replacement. Second, he learned that delivering a newspaper requires an address, and the printer’s truck driver refused to drop off the 50,000 copies to Portnoy’s home in Swampscott because the street was too narrow. So Portnoy met the truck on the Lynnway and offloaded thousands of papers into his father’s minivan.

Distribution was the next nightmare. He hired homeless men to hand out the paper, paying them $150 each. But when he drove by the first drop point, he saw the men sitting on a bench, drinking 40s, wearing the Barstool shirts he’d given them. The papers were untouched. Frustrated and out thousands of dollars, he fired them on the spot. That day, he learned an expensive lesson: you can’t just throw money at a problem without thinking about human nature.

Finding a Better Distribution Method

Week two meant sink-or-swim. The obvious question: how do you get people to actually take a free paper? Portnoy realized he’d never accept a newspaper from a homeless man, but if a pretty girl handed it to him? That changed everything. He contracted a modeling agency called Candy Ford to hire local girls to distribute the paper. The first girl he met was Renee, who later became a key figure in the Barstool story.

But the homeless fiasco left a mess — leftover shirts that said “Barstool Sports” across the front. Portnoy started selling them for $15 in the paper, calling them “Ugly Shirts.” He kept a running tally of sales in each issue. That humble merchandise line became the company’s first real revenue engine, eventually evolving into a multimillion-dollar business that would sustain Barstool for the next two decades.

The Cover Girls and the Real Grind

A reader named Eric Levin reached out with an offer: he would professionally photograph local girls for the cover, Maxim-style, if Portnoy could find models. Renee volunteered two of her friends — Jillian and Luba — for the first shoot. That cover became the template for the next six years: every issue featured local women. It gave the paper a visual hook that stood out on newsstands.

Beyond the glamour, Portnoy did everything himself: writing, selling ads, delivering, and cleaning newsracks. He once had to scrub actual human feces out of a rack. When the city impounded dirty racks, he’d hunt them down, pay the fines, and haul them back. The ink never washed off his hands, and his car was a rolling disaster zone of newspapers and cleaning solution. But he was in it. No more talking — just doing.

Key Takeaways

• Start before you’re ready: Portnoy launched with a logo that couldn’t print and a distribution plan that failed immediately, but he corrected course fast.
• Understand human behavior: Switching from homeless distributors to attractive models solved the fundamental problem of getting people to pick up the paper.
• Turn mistakes into revenue: The Ugly Shirts, born from a failed experiment, became a core business line that kept the company alive for years.
• Grit over glamour: Behind every successful launch are dirty newsracks, late nights, and doing the jobs no one else will do.

If you like this summary, you probably also like these summaries...

Crisis and Renewal

by S. Steven Pan

The Price of Mercy

by Emily Galvin Almanza

The Price of Time

by Edward Chancellor

Chapter 2: Chapter 2: Internet 1.0

Overview

The newspaper business was a losing game—every extra copy sold meant more paper, more ink, more gas for the delivery route. It was a business model where success actually made things worse. The math never worked. But the shift to a website changed everything: suddenly, content could be created, shared, and consumed without the crushing weight of physical distribution. It felt like escaping a gravity well.

The chapter also lays bare the raw, unfiltered nature of early Barstool blogging. There was no strategy, no editorial oversight, no careful brand management. Just a guy (and a small crew) finding funny stuff online, posting it, and moving on. The audience grew because the content was what guys actually talked about—sports, girls, gambling, weird videos from parties. It was pre-social-media social media: people sent Barstool clips that had nowhere else to go. The growth felt accidental, like a band blowing up and wondering, What the hell is happening?

But the transition wasn't just technical—it was personal. Blogging demanded speed, concision, constant output. The original writers, who had toiled for six or seven years for zero pay, were aging out. The joke had been sustained by pure love of the game, but the game was changing. The website became the perfect breaking point: a moment to move on, even as Portnoy, living at his girlfriend's mom's place and still broke, sensed something real was finally happening.

Key Takeaways

• Print was a trap: More readers meant more costs, not more profit—a fundamental scaling problem.
• Blogging changed the rules: Speed and volume trumped depth; content became cheap to produce and distribute.
• Early Barstool filled a void: Pre-Instagram/TikTok, it was the only place for user-generated, guys-at-a-bar-style videos and jokes.
• The original crew had to leave: After years of unpaid passion, the website's arrival signaled a natural (and necessary) exit for those who couldn't commit full-time.
• Success felt accidental: Growth came organically from sharing, not marketing—and the creator himself was surprised by it.

Chapter 3: Chapter 3: The Lessons of the Newspaper

Overview

A pivotal period began when Barstool Sports started generating real revenue and launched its first serious expansion beyond the one-man operation. The money from t-shirt sales and Blogads allowed Dave to consider hiring help for the first time, but the path to building a team was messy, personal, and full of hard-won lessons about both business and human nature. From family fights over retirement accounts to the viral explosion of a makeup tutorial, early success forced difficult decisions and introduced the voices that would define Barstool’s future.

T-shirts, Trust, and the First Real Money

The t-shirt business was raw entrepreneurship at its finest. Dave and his family—Renee and his parents—would pack and ship shirts for days on end, chasing any cultural moment that could be printed on cotton. Viral videos like the Leprechaun sighting, movie quotes from Point Break and Jaws—anything that resonated with the audience became merchandise. For the first time, Dave’s bank account began to grow. But growing meant trusting his mother with the company accounts, which led to an absurd fight when she siphoned money into a retirement fund without asking. “YOU’RE STEALING FROM ME! YOU COULD GO TO JAIL FOR THAT!” he yelled, even though the money was technically going into his own future. The episode reveals how blurred the lines were between family, trust, and control in those early days. Dave was still learning that financial success came with new kinds of conflict.

Jenna and the Viral Explosion

Revenue opened the door to hiring. The first non-Gaz employee came from the Stoola (women’s side) experiment. Jenna, the “Local Smokeshow of the Day” for that site, became a contributor Dave treated like a little sister, feeding her content ideas and seeing what she could do. Then came the Friday afternoon in July 2010 when she posted a two-minute YouTube tutorial titled “How to trick people into thinking you're good looking.” It was a simple, funny makeup transformation—goblin to bombshell in minutes. That video exploded, proving that personality and humor could sell just as easily on video as on a blog page. The lesson was clear: Barstool’s formula worked beyond the written word, and Jenna had unlocked a new channel.

Finding a Voice in New York

The next big move was expanding to New York. Dave needed a blogger who could capture the same energy but with a NYC flavor. Enter Kevin. A die-hard Mets, Jets, and Knicks fan, Kevin was trapped auditing collateralized debt obligations in 2008—the very CDOs that had cratered the economy. He hated his cube job and started a side blog, ForSureNot.com, writing every day for a tiny audience of about five hundred readers. When Dave read his stuff, he recognized the tormented, fatalistic complaining that made Kevin’s voice jump off the page. Desperate to escape his desk, Kevin had become a natural fit. But there was a problem: Keith Markovich (KMarko) was also a strong contender for the same job. Dave only had money for one. The chapter ends with Dave stuck between two great candidates, unable to decide—a classic early-growth dilemma that would echo throughout Barstool’s history.

Key Takeaways

• T-shirt revenue proved the business model could scale, but financial success brought messy personal conflicts (e.g., family fights over retirement savings).
• Viral moments can come from unexpected places—Jenna’s makeup tutorial showed that video content could amplify Barstool’s reach far beyond written blogs.
• Hiring for voice over résumé paid off: Kevin’s misery as a CDO auditor translated into relatable, fatalistic writing that resonated with readers.
• Early growth meant making hard choices with limited resources—choosing between two talented candidates with only one salary to offer.

Chapter 4: Chapter 4: Stoolapalooza

Overview

Chapter 4 captures the chaotic, electrifying moment when Barstool Sports stopped being a side project and started feeling like an unstoppable force. The Stoolapalooza tour wasn’t just a college concert series—it was a trial by fire that proved our fans were real, our reach was legitimate, and I had no intention of ever going back to a cubicle. By the end of this chapter, the old life was dead and gone.

Meeting Dante the Don

You don’t plan moments that change your trajectory. They just show up. That’s how I met Dante the Don—a local guy who reached out, I said yes for reasons I still can’t explain, and he pitched me on becoming Sammy Adams’s DJ for the tour. I didn’t even know Sammy needed a DJ. Honestly, I’m not sure Sammy knew he needed one either. But that was the energy of the whole operation: fly by the seat of your pants, figure it out on the ground.

The First Barstool Black Card Tour

Those shows were a revelation. Every venue we hit was packed with students who knew every single lyric to every Sammy song. It was the kind of crowd response that silenced any doubt about whether the numbers were real. Sammy’s iTunes stats had been questioned by skeptics, but after seeing those rooms, I knew the truth. And when people came at him, I was out there defending him like he was family. Shoot first, ask questions later. That loyalty wasn’t about understanding the music industry—it was about protecting one of our own.

The UNH Showdown with SCOPE

The real drama came at the University of New Hampshire. The student-run SCOPE organization refused to let us use their venue. They told me I didn’t know how to throw a proper college concert. That condescension lit a fire. I didn’t ask them for money—I just needed the building, like every other school had given us. When they brushed me off, I did what Barstool does best: I aired them out on the blog. Posting the full email back-and-forth turned SCOPE into the villain. By the time we rolled into UNH, “FUCK SCOPE” signs were everywhere. I didn’t feel bad. They made their bed, and they got to sleep in it. That philosophy—show the good, the bad, the ugly—became the bedrock of how I ran the business. It made fans feel invested, not just entertained.

The Aftermath and Realization

By the end of the tour, I was running on fumes. But exhaustion came with clarity. For the first time since starting Barstool Sports, I knew with absolute certainty: I was never going back to the cubes. The little engine that could was no longer little. Stoolapalooza had proven we were far more popular than I ever dreamed. A new era had begun, and there was no turning back.

Key Takeaways

• The tour validated that Barstool’s fanbase was real, passionate, and deeply connected to the brand.
• Being transparent—even when it meant exposing conflict—built trust and loyalty with readers.
• Sometimes saying yes to random people (like Dante) leads to the biggest breakthroughs.
• The UNH SCOPE incident taught me that public accountability works better than private negotiation.
• Stoolapalooza marked the moment Barstool stopped being a side hustle and became a permanent mission.