Chapters 1-6

Chapter 1 of 4
0:000:00
EN
1x
Voice
PDF

Head Under Water

by Kiersten Modglin

Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

⚠️ READER ADVISORY: This is a deep-dive summary designed for those who want the full story. Contains spoilers.

Head Under Water book cover

What is the book Head Under Water about?

Kiersten Modglin's Head Under Water follows Opal as she returns to her hometown to grieve her mother, takes a teaching job at her old elementary school, and is forced into a fake friendship with Will, the ex she can barely stand, while quiet accidents begin piling up around her.

FeatureInsta.PageBlinkist
Head Under Water✓✕
Summary DepthFull Chapter-by-Chapter15-min overview
Audio Narration✓✓
Full access to all 800+ summaries✓✓
Visual Mindmaps✓✕
AI Q&A✓✕
Missing a book? Request it, usually live within 48h✓✕
Quizzes✓✕
PDF Downloads✓✕
Send to Kindle✓✓
Price$89.99/yr$146/yr (PRO)
*Competitor data last verified July 2026.

1 Page Summary

In Head Under Water by Kiersten Modglin, Opal returns to the hometown she fled seven years ago to grieve her mother, Ruth—only to find that the past she tried to bury is still waiting for her. Taking a third-grade teaching job at her old elementary school forces her to walk daily past the locked doors of her childhood and into proximity with Will, the person she once loved and now can barely stand. When a college assignment throws them together, the two agree to fake a friendship to survive the semester, a transaction they both insist costs them nothing—though the forced closeness begins to do its slow, unwanted work.

Complicating everything is Banks, a quiet, single-minded man whose arrival in Opal's life rekindles an old crush and offers something that feels steadier than the pull of the past. As Opal wrestles with grief, an estranged family, and the question of which version of her future she can bear to want, small accidents and unsettling moments start to accumulate around her—raising suspicions she can't confirm and no one else wants to entertain. Someone, it seems, may be watching.

Tense, atmospheric, and steeped in the ache of old wounds and unfinished love, Head Under Water is a story about the people we can't quite leave behind and the secrets that refuse to stay submerged. Readers who love slow-burning domestic suspense with a heavy emotional core—fans of small-town secrets, complicated romance, and heroines caught between protecting the people they love and protecting themselves—will find themselves holding their breath.

Chapters 1-6

The water closes over Opal's head and the world narrows to a fight she is losing. A man's hands hold her under, and she thrashes against him with everything she has, clawing for the surface, for air, for any purchase that will let her break free. He is stronger. He does not let go. The struggle drains out of her limb by limb until the darkness takes her and she knows nothing more.

Seven Years Gone

Opal comes back to the town she left seven years ago, and the reason she comes back is her mother. Ruth is dead, and the grief sits in that house like a presence with its own weight. Opal visits, and the visit carries all the awkwardness of a long absence pressed up against fresh loss, the two of them circling each other in a space where Ruth's absence is louder than anything either of them says. The house itself seems to hold the loss in its walls, and every room Opal passes through carries the reminder that Ruth is not there and will not be there again. The silence between Opal and her mother is not the comfortable silence of people who know each other well. It is the silence of seven years of distance trying to find something to say in the face of a death that has rearranged everything.

Then her mother tells her the plan she and Margie have already made. There will be no staying at home. A room has been arranged for Opal, shared with a roommate, and the decision is presented as a settled thing rather than something to discuss. Opal's return, which she had imagined as coming back to her family, is rerouted before it can begin. Her mother has handed her off, kindly and firmly, to a stranger's apartment. The plan is not offered as a question or a suggestion. It is delivered as a fact, already decided between the two mothers, and Opal is left to absorb the news that the homecoming she had pictured for herself is not the one that has been arranged for her. Her mother's kindness does not soften the sting of being managed, of having her return to town shaped by someone else's hands before she has even had a chance to settle into it.

The Roommate

Opal drives to the apartment expecting nothing in particular and finds Will. Will, of all people, her childhood rival, standing in the doorway of the room she is supposed to live in. The recognition lands on both of them at once, and neither one takes it well. Opal protests the arrangement outright. Will protests it just as hard. Each of them refuses, flatly and immediately, to live with the other, and for a moment the whole plan seems ready to collapse under the weight of their shared history. The doorway becomes a standoff, the two of them staring at each other across years of bad feeling, and neither is willing to be the one who backs down first. The absurdity of the situation is not lost on either of them, but the absurdity does not make it any easier to accept. Of all the people in town, of all the rooms that could have been arranged, it had to be this one, and it had to be him.

But Will has information that changes the shape of the moment. The police investigation into Ruth's death is still open. It never closed. Both of their mothers have been questioned, and the fact hangs in the air between them, recasting the awkward reunion into something with an edge to it. Ruth's death is not a settled grief in this town. It is an active question, and the people closest to it have already been pulled into the asking. The revelation shifts the ground under the argument about the apartment. What had been a petty dispute about living arrangements becomes something larger and more unsettling, a reminder that the death that brought Opal back to town is not finished with any of them. Will does not deliver the information gently or with any particular care. He states it plainly, and the plainness of it is what makes it land so hard. The investigation is open. Their mothers have been questioned. The words sit between them and neither of them can pretend the argument about the room is the most important thing in the doorway anymore.

Old Wounds

Standing in that doorway, Opal remembers exactly who Will was to her. She remembers him mocking her as a teenager, the casual cruelty of it, and she remembers being excluded from kickball with Cory, shut out of the game by Will's say-so. The memories are not abstract grievances. They are specific, sharp, and they explain precisely why the sight of him in her new apartment feels less like coincidence and more like an insult. The mockery had been the kind of thing that should have been small, the sort of childhood cruelty that people are supposed to outgrow and forget, but Opal has not forgotten it. She remembers the sting of it, the way it had made her feel small and excluded, and she remembers the kickball game with a clarity that seven years have not dulled. Being shut out of the game by Will's say-so had been a small thing in the scheme of a childhood, but it had been one of many small things, and the accumulation of them is what she carries with her into this doorway. The sight of him standing in her new apartment does not feel like a coincidence. It feels like an insult, like the universe has arranged one more small cruelty at his hands, and the fact that their mothers arranged it does not make it feel any less like his doing.

A Few Days

Despite everything, Opal agrees to stay. Not permanently, and not because she has softened toward Will. She stays a few days, until she can find her own place, and she stays to keep their mothers happy. The two women who arranged this room have their own stake in it, and Opal, already carrying the guilt of seven years away and the weight of Ruth's death, cannot bring herself to blow the arrangement up on the first day. It is a truce, not a reconciliation, and both of them know it. The agreement is grudging on both sides, a temporary accommodation that neither of them is happy about, and the terms of it are clear without being spoken aloud. She will stay a few days. She will look for her own place. She will not make a scene that their mothers will have to hear about. The truce holds because neither of them is willing to be the one who breaks it first, and because the guilt Opal carries is heavier than her resentment of Will, at least for now.

Will shows her the apartment. Opal walks through it expecting to be unimpressed, braced for another reason to resent the situation, and instead finds herself impressed despite herself. The space is good. It is better than she wants it to be, and her reluctance makes the appreciation more grudging, not less. She had been prepared to find fault with everything, to catalog the flaws and use them as further evidence that the arrangement was a mistake, but the apartment does not cooperate with her plan. The rooms are well kept. The light is good. The space has been cared for in a way that suggests someone has put thought into it, and Opal resents the care almost as much as she would have resented neglect. Her appreciation is grudging because she does not want to give Will the satisfaction of having done something well, and the fact that she cannot help but notice it makes her more resistant, not less.

Then Will makes a joke, promising he won't kill her, and something flickers across his face. It is there and gone, a strange expression that does not match the lightness of the words. Opal notices it. The joke lands differently than it was meant to, and the question of what Will is carrying, and what he knows about Ruth, settles quietly into the room alongside her. The words themselves are the kind of thing anyone might say to break the tension of showing a reluctant roommate around a new apartment, but the expression that accompanies them is not the expression of someone making a harmless joke. It is something else, something that passes over his face too quickly for Opal to name, and the quickness of it is what makes it stick with her. She does not ask about it. She does not know how to ask about it without giving away that she noticed, and she is not sure she wants to know the answer. But the question settles into the room alongside her and does not leave.

Will leads Opal through the apartment, showing her the rooms and offering her one of her own, his aim plainly to convince her to stay. She gives in only grudgingly, agreeing to remain a day or two, and the small victory costs him more than it gains. On her way through, Opal scuffs the refinished stairs with her heel, a petty strike meant to spite him. It changes nothing except to confirm the hostility running both ways between them. The scuff is a small thing, the kind of thing that could be accidental if she wanted it to be, but it is not accidental and both of them know it. It is a message, petty and small, that she is not happy about being here and that she is not going to make the arrangement easy for him. Will does not say anything about it. He does not have to. The scuff sits on the refinished stairs as evidence of exactly how things stand between them, and the hostility runs both ways, confirmed and unspoken.

Move-In Day

Will and Margie leave for Havenport on move-in day, wanting Will settled into his new life, and Opal is left behind with Cory, feeling abandoned to her brother's presence. She complains to her mother that Will ruins everything, wanting nothing so much as to escape him, but the complaint costs her her mother's patience. Her mother insists that Will and Cory are her family, refusing to entertain the grievance. The insistence is firm and final, the kind of statement that is meant to close the subject rather than open it, and Opal is left with the uncomfortable sense that her grievance has been weighed and found wanting. Then she hugs Opal and promises that college is big enough to avoid Will, trying to reassure her. The promise does not convince her. The hug is warm and the words are meant kindly, but the reassurance lands flat, because Opal has already learned that the arrangements made by their mothers have a way of putting Will in her path no matter how big the campus is supposed to be. The promise is meant to comfort her, and it does not.

The Dorm

In the dorm, Opal meets Jess, and the two of them scan the Welcome Week events together, wanting to plan their social calendar. It sets a shared agenda between them. The scanning of the events is a small act of friendship, the first of its kind for Opal in this new place, and it gives the two of them something to do together that is not about the past or about Will or about the death that brought Opal back to town. It is a plan, a shared calendar, a way of moving forward. Opal's mother urges them to attend every event and to leave their door open, wanting them to be social, which only embarrasses Opal. The urging is well meant and badly received, the kind of motherly advice that lands as an embarrassment rather than an encouragement, and Opal feels the heat of it in her face as her mother goes on about the importance of putting herself out there. She reminisces about Havenport as a magical place, wanting to share her excitement, but the nostalgia deepens Opal's dread of losing her. The reminiscence is meant to be a gift, a passing down of something the mother loved, but it lands as a weight instead, because Opal can hear in her mother's voice how much this place means to her and how much she wants Opal to love it the same way. The dread of losing her deepens with every word, because the more her mother loves this place, the more Opal will have to lose when the time comes to say goodbye. Opal tells her mother to leave and find Margie, wanting to stand on her own, and has to hold back tears as she does it. The words are harder to say than she expected, and the tears are harder to hold back, because telling her mother to go is not the same as wanting her to go, and the difference between the two is what makes her eyes sting. Her mother hugs her goodbye and extracts a promise that she will call every Saturday, wanting to stay connected. The promise is a small thread of connection, a way of keeping the two of them tied together across the distance, and Opal gives it willingly even as she struggles to keep her composure. Then she is gone, and Opal is officially on her own. The goodbye leaves a silence behind it that is different from the silence of the house where Ruth's absence sits like a presence.

💡 Try clicking the AI chat button to ask questions about this book!

Chapters 7-13

The Party

At the party, Jess announces she wants to hook up with Will, and Opal's last ally of the night abandons her when Jess leaves with him. Opal is left alone in the crowd, and the loss stings less as heartbreak than as another small proof that she is easy to leave behind.

Determined to forget Will, Opal finds King and dances with him, throwing herself into the distraction. But when a flicker of disappointment crosses King's face, it triggers the old, familiar feeling in Opal that she is not enough. The moment she reaches for escape, the night hands her back the same wound she was trying to outrun.

The Classroom and the Hallway

Opal takes the third-grade teaching job at her old elementary school, a decision that forces her to walk daily past the locked doors and buried memories of her childhood with Will. The building holds their history in its walls, and taking the job means confronting all of it.

Then Banks surprises Opal in her classroom. He reveals that he grew up in Clinton, and the disclosure rekindles her college crush and her hope. For a moment the room feels full of possibility again.

That hope collides with the past when Will appears at the school for Parents' Day. Opal is shocked, and the shock deepens when she realizes Will has a child at the school. The boy she knew is a father, and she knew nothing about it.

Worse, or stranger, Will and Banks greet each other as friends. The easy familiarity between them unsettles Opal and leaves her wondering what happened between the two men after college, and what it means that her old heartbreak and her new hope apparently share a history she was never part of.

Opal leaves Banks and Will in the hallway and returns to her class, torn between what could have been and the life she is actually living. She carries the split with her back through the door.

The Teachers' Lounge

George gives Opal a tour of the teachers' lounge, and the ordinary room dissolves a mysterious childhood rumor into something mundane and welcoming. What was once a site of childish speculation becomes just a room with a coffee machine and colleagues, and the tour begins a new friendship.

Opal offers to bring her Nespresso to the lounge, a small gesture that signals she is starting to put down roots at the school. It is the first thing she has offered the place rather than merely survived in it.

Statistics Class

In statistics class, Will sits behind Opal and taunts her about a birthday pimple, breaking his usual distance from her. The teasing is familiar and deliberate, a way of being close without admitting he wants to be.

Banks takes the seat next to Opal and introduces himself, giving her a new romantic interest and a reason to look forward to class. The contrast between the two men sharpens everything.

Professor Gene announces a volunteer position with a guaranteed passing grade, and the prize pushes Opal to compete for it. Opal writes her name on Professor Gene's volunteer list, setting herself up to be chosen.

Will mocks Opal for drooling over Banks, and their usual sparring escalates into open jealousy. The jab lands harder than either of them pretends.

Then Professor Gene reveals that Will is Opal's new partner for the class project. The announcement traps them together and turns both their plans upside down. Whatever Opal hoped to build with Banks, and whatever distance Will hoped to keep, the project binds them to each other instead.

Will's Apartment

Opal returns to Will's apartment expecting solitude, and the empty quiet forces her to admit the truth she has been avoiding: she has stayed too long, and her hope about Banks has gone unanswered. The apartment that once felt like a refuge now measures the length of her waiting, and she can no longer pretend the arrangement is temporary or that someone else is coming to change it.

Opal comes home from the reunion frustrated and wanting nothing more than to be alone, but Will follows her and pushes his way into her room. She asks about his kid, and the question costs her the peace she was after, turning a moment of retreat into a conversation she cannot escape.

In the kitchen, Opal presses Will on why she never knew he had a son. He turns it back on her, making her admit how little she actually knows about him, and the accusation lands because it is true. Will then reveals his son is seven years old. The number stops Opal cold: Will has been a father for years without her knowing, and the discovery shifts how she sees him, recasting the person she thought she understood.

Opal starts to ask who the mother is, then stops herself, deciding the question is too invasive. Instead she asks the boy's name. Will says the boy is named Richard, called Richie, and Opal recognizes the name. The recognition unlocks the truth: the child is Cory's son, which makes him Will's nephew. The revelation reframes everything Will has said, and Opal's anger spikes. She throws a towel at him for misleading her, and Will explains that Cory had a work emergency and he offered to help. The excuse does not erase the fact that he let her believe otherwise.

Will then asks about Opal's reunion with Banks, clearly wanting to tease her. She deflects, refusing to give him the reaction he is fishing for, and the sparring between them stays sharp even as the subject changes.

Will cooks chicken and sets a plate in front of Opal. She suspects he might tamper with it, so he eats a bite first to prove it is safe, and the small gesture of proof eases the tension between them.

Opal asks Will what she should know about Ruth. He confirms that Ruth drowned in the bathtub after drinking. Then he reveals that police found something about a sleeping pill, and the ground shifts under Opal: the death might have been an accident, self-inflicted, or murder. The ambiguity opens a door she cannot close.

Opal wonders why her mother never told her about the sleeping pill. The unanswered question leaves her unsettled, and the chapter closes on that unease, with the truth about Ruth still out of reach.

Chapters 14-18

Opal and Will agree to fake a friendship to survive Professor Gene's paired volunteer assignment, trading their mutual hatred for a semester of tolerated teamwork. Neither can afford to fail the course, so they treat the arrangement as a pure transaction. The deal changes the shape of their daily life, forcing them into proximity they would never have chosen. What neither of them says aloud is that the arrangement is a survival tactic, a way to keep their grades intact while keeping each other at arm's length, and the terms are simple enough that they can pretend it costs them nothing. It costs them plenty. The fake friendship seeps into the ordinary hours of their weeks, into shared silences and forced conversations and the small negotiations of two people who would rather be anywhere else, and the proximity does its slow work whether they consent to it or not.

Opal spots Banks entering the library and panics as Will loudly invites him over, forcing her to endure Will's teasing about her crush. Will calls out with theatrical enthusiasm before she can hide, enjoying every second of her discomfort. The ambush changes the encounter from a chance sighting into a public humiliation she cannot escape. She had wanted the sighting to stay a sighting, a private flutter she could carry home and examine at her leisure, and instead Will turns it into a performance with an audience of one, and she has to sit inside it and smile while her face burns. The panic is the point for Will, or at least the entertainment is, and he savors it openly, and the moment teaches Opal that the fake friendship has given him a new instrument to play her with.

Banks reveals he is a PhD student and teaching assistant, and Opal grows more drawn to his steadiness while Will watches her with an unreadable intensity. The revelation makes Banks more real and more within reach, and Opal finds herself calmer in his presence. Will's teasing goes quiet, something harder settling behind his eyes, and the shift changes the balance of the room. The title lands on Banks like a fact that organizes him, and Opal feels the ground of him solidify, a man with a path and a position and a steadiness she can lean toward. Will's silence is louder than his teasing was. Something behind his eyes closes like a door, and the room rearranges itself around the new information, and Opal notices the quiet without understanding it.

Will tells Opal that Banks was jealous and offers to flirt with her to provoke more jealousy, but she refuses and the tension between them shifts. He presents himself as a tool she could use, and she turns him down flat. The refusal changes what was sharp and combative into something charged and unnamed that lingers after she walks away. He makes the offer casually, as though it were a favor, as though he were handing her a key to a door she had not asked to open, and she refuses before he finishes the sentence. The refusal does not end the thing between them. It redirects it. What was sharp and combative becomes charged and unnamed, and it follows her out of the room and down the hall and does not leave when she does.

Opal wakes Saturday to an empty apartment and drives to surprise her mother, only to find Will already there fixing things around the house. The silence of her own place feels wrong, so she acts on impulse, and the surprise ends up being hers. Will has beaten her to it, settled in as though he belongs, and the discovery changes how she sees his place in her mother's life. The empty apartment presses on her, the quiet of it wrong in a way she cannot name, and she gets in the car and drives because the alternative is sitting in that silence. She arrives expecting to be the surprise. Instead Will is on the roof or under the sink or wherever the house has failed, tools in hand, comfortable in the space, and her mother moves around him as though he has always been there. The surprise is hers, and it rearranges her understanding of how much room Will occupies in her mother's life.

Will cooks Opal pancakes and boxes her in at the stove, showing he remembers exactly how she likes them, unsettling her with the intimacy. He works the small kitchen space so she cannot escape him, every detail of the pancakes exactly right. Being known so precisely changes her from teased to exposed, and she cannot process how he learned her so well. He does not ask how she likes them. He already knows, and he proves it with the batter and the pan and the timing, and he arranges himself in the kitchen so that she is cornered between the counter and his arm and the stove. The precision is the unsettling part. Anyone can remember a preference. Will remembers the whole of it, the way she takes them, the way she does not, and she stands there exposed by his attention and cannot work out when he learned her or why he kept the knowledge.

Will gives up his steak dinner so Opal and her mother can share it, then leaves after a lingering touch, deepening Opal's confusion about his motives. He makes the sacrifice without a show, and the touch at the door stays with her after he goes. The gesture changes her read of him again, leaving her unable to tell what he wants or whether he knows himself. He does not announce the sacrifice. He simply makes it, sliding the plate toward them and stepping back, and the lack of performance makes it harder to dismiss. At the door his hand lingers, a touch that lasts a beat too long to be casual, and it stays with her after the door closes. She has read him as a tormentor, a transaction partner, a threat, a tool, and now she has to add this, a man who gives up his dinner and touches her at the door, and she cannot tell what he wants or whether he knows himself.

Opal sees a cryptic text on her mother's phone asking "What did we do?" and her mother dismisses it as a scam before pocketing the phone. The deflection is smooth, too smooth, and the question lodges in Opal's mind. The moment changes her from comfortable in her mother's house to watchful, alert to what is being kept from her. The text is brief and strange and it lands in Opal's chest like a stone. Her mother's dismissal comes too quickly, too smoothly, the phone disappearing into a pocket before Opal can read it again, and the smoothness is what sticks. A scam would earn a shrug. This earns a performance. Opal goes from comfortable in her mother's house to watchful, and the watchfulness does not switch off.

Opal asks her mother about the investigation into Ruth's death, and her mother calls it hogwash and refuses to discuss it, shutting the conversation down. The door closes entirely, and Opal is left on the other side of it. The refusal changes the investigation from a distant rumor into a wall between them, one her mother will not let her climb. The word hogwash is delivered flatly, finally, in a tone that ends the subject rather than answers it, and Opal stands on the other side of a door that has been closed in her face. What was a distant rumor becomes a wall, and the wall is between her and her mother now, and her mother will not let her climb it.

Opal finds Banks on a bench at the Beacon Pavilion and, after an awkward approach, sits with him. She is uncertain of her welcome and hesitates before committing to the seat. The choice changes a chance meeting into a deliberate one, and she stays. She almost does not approach. The hesitation is real, her welcome uncertain, and she stands at the edge of the moment deciding whether to claim it. Then she sits, and the sitting is the choice, and the chance meeting becomes a deliberate one, and she stays.

Banks asks Opal whether she and Will are involved, and she insists there is nothing between them. She means it, even if the words feel more complicated than they should. The denial changes the air between them, clearing the way for what comes next. The question is careful and direct, and her answer comes fast, and she means it. The words feel more complicated than they should as they leave her mouth, but she means them, and the denial clears the air, and what comes next becomes possible because of it.

Banks asks Opal out on a date, and she accepts. The question is direct and the answer is immediate, and the acceptance changes everything that follows, setting her on a path she cannot walk back from. He asks without hedging, and she answers without pausing, and the immediacy of it is its own kind of declaration. The acceptance sets her on a path, and the path does not run backward, and everything that follows follows from this.

Banks finds Opal and confesses that he likes her, then asks her out. The admission carries real risk: the TA disclosure hangs over them, and pursuing anything could complicate their positions. Opal accepts, and the dynamic between them shifts from professional caution to something openly personal. He says the words plainly, that he likes her, and the plainness is what makes the risk visible. He is a teaching assistant. She is a student. The disclosure hangs over them both, and pursuing anything could complicate their positions, and he asks anyway. She accepts, and the dynamic between them shifts from professional caution to something openly personal, and the shift is not small.

The moment does not last. Will interrupts, dragging Opal away to see Professor Gene and costing her the rest of her conversation with Banks. Opal confronts Will for ruining everything, wanting him to back off and stop interfering in her life. Will warns her that she could lose her scholarship, a threat that strains the trust between them. He then reveals his real motive: he cares because her mom would blame him if anything went wrong. The stakes of Opal's choices now run through her family as much as through her own future. Will arrives like a weather event, pulling her away with Professor Gene as the excuse, and the conversation with Banks is over before it finishes. Opal confronts him, and the confrontation is about everything now, not just the interruption, and she tells him to back off and stop interfering in her life. He warns her about the scholarship, and the warning lands as a threat, and the trust between them strains under it. Then he gives her the real reason, that he cares because her mom would blame him if anything went wrong, and the stakes rearrange themselves. Her choices run through her family now as much as through her own future, and Will has made himself the hinge of that.

Professor Gene orders both Opal and Will to attend a conference next weekend, forcing them together whether they want it or not. The order is not a request, and there is no version of the weekend where they are not together, and the forced proximity extends the arrangement past the semester's ordinary hours into a trip neither of them chose.

The Birthday

On Opal's birthday, Tonya announces it to the class, exposing Opal's age to her students. Opal redirects the class into a telling-time lesson, deflecting the birthday attention at the cost of student groans. Kennedy reassures Opal that she isn't old, softening her embarrassment. Then the students gift her a handmade paper crown, and the gesture moves her to tears. Tonya's announcement is cheerful and public and entirely without malice, and it exposes Opal's age to a room of students, and Opal deflects the attention the only way she can, turning the moment into a telling-time lesson and absorbing the student groans as the price of escape. Kennedy leans in to reassure her that she isn't old, and the reassurance softens the embarrassment. Then the students give her a handmade paper crown, and the gesture is so earnest and so small and so entirely from them that it moves her to tears.

Banks knocks and asks to borrow Opal's keys after locking his in the lounge, interrupting her celebration. Opal lends him the keys, hoping for reciprocity, and briefly expects something more from him. But Banks leaves without noticing her birthday, disappointing Opal and changing how she feels about the day. The knock comes in the middle of the celebration, and Banks needs her keys because his are locked in the lounge, and she lends them gladly, hoping the favor will be returned in kind, expecting something more from him than the errand. He takes the keys and goes, and he does not notice the crown or the day or what it means, and the disappointment settles over the birthday and changes how she feels about it.

Chapters 19-23

The Birthday That Isn't

Opal has plans for her birthday. She wants to spend it with her mother, and she carries that hope into the day, the way you carry something fragile that you have decided not to drop. The plan is simple and specific: a celebration with her mother, the two of them, a dinner that belongs to them. But when she learns her mother is sick, everything shifts. The illness is not a small thing that can be worked around. It is the kind of thing that reorganizes a day, that takes the shape out of it and leaves something formless in its place. The dinner has to be postponed, and with that postponement Opal loses her birthday plans entirely. What she wanted was simple and specific, a celebration with her mother, and illness takes it from her, leaving her with a day that no longer has a shape. The loss is not dramatic. It is quiet and total. The day she had built in her mind is gone, and what remains is a birthday that isn't, a date on the calendar that no longer points to anything.

The Sound Through the Wall

Later, Opal hears sounds coming from Will's room and wants to check on him, worried something is wrong. The concern is ordinary, the kind of thing anyone might feel hearing something unexplained through a wall. She approaches the door with that concern, ready to knock, ready to ask if he is all right. What she discovers instead is Will masturbating. The moment lands hard. It is not something she can unsee or unhear, and it is not something she can pretend did not happen. She is left ashamed and angry, the embarrassment burning on both sides of a door she never should have approached. The concern she felt curdles into something she cannot set down. It follows her back to her own room, sits with her, refuses to be dismissed. The shame is not only hers. It is the shame of having seen something private, of having crossed a line she did not mean to cross, and the anger is the anger of being put in that position at all.

A Bath That Washes Nothing Away

Opal tries to wash off the day in a bath, wanting the water to reset her. The bath is meant to be a boundary, a line between the day and whatever comes after. But she is haunted by thoughts of Will and of Ruth, and the bath offers no escape. The turmoil follows her into the water. There is no clean break, no quiet, only the same circling thoughts of the two people she cannot stop thinking about. The water does not reset anything. It only holds her while the thoughts go around and around, Will and Ruth, Ruth and Will, the two of them occupying the same crowded space in her mind. She wanted the bath to be an ending. Instead it is just more of the same, the day continuing even as she tries to wash it away.

Two Cars, One Stubborn Silence

Will wants to attend the conference independently, on his own terms. The independence matters to him, the idea that he can go where he is going without being folded into someone else's arrangements. Instead he is forced to drive separately from Opal, and the arrangement deepens their stubborn rivalry rather than resolving it. Neither of them bends. The separation on the road mirrors the distance between them, and the stubbornness on both sides makes the drive its own small battle. Two cars, one road, the same destination, and yet the whole thing feels like a contest neither of them agreed to enter. The drive is not a truce. It is a continuation of whatever is between them, carried out at highway speed, each of them alone with the choice to be alone.

The Tease at the Conference

At the conference, Opal wants to avoid Will. The avoidance is deliberate, a plan she has made for herself, a way of keeping the distance the separate cars established. He does not let her. He approaches her and teases her about homework, and the teasing unsettles her. She came wanting distance and instead gets his attention, light and needling, closing the gap she was trying to keep open. The tease is not cruel. It is worse than cruel in its way, because it is familiar, because it assumes a closeness she is trying to deny. He finds her, he needles her, and the distance she wanted collapses into something smaller, something she cannot maintain.

Will Goes His Own Way

Will wants to explore the area rather than attend the sessions. The conference is not the point for him, or at least not the only point. Opal warns him, and he dismisses the warnings. The divide between them widens. He chooses wandering over obligation, and she is left with the warnings unheeded and the gap between their choices growing. The warnings are real, or at least they are real to her, and his dismissal of them is its own kind of statement. He goes his own way, and she is left with the space he vacated, the gap between what she would have chosen and what he did choose.

Dinner for One, Interrupted

Opal wants to eat dinner alone in her room, keeping to herself. The solitude is the plan, the same plan as the avoidance, the same attempt to hold a line. Will intercepts her and persuades her to hang out, and her isolation breaks. She had wanted solitude and instead gets his company, the wall she was building coming down whether she likes it or not. The persuasion works because he is persistent and because some part of her does not resist as hard as she might have. The dinner alone becomes dinner with Will, and the isolation she wanted is gone, replaced by the thing she was trying to avoid.

An Escape Room as Friendship Practice

Will wants to practice being friends, and he proposes an escape room. The proposal is strange and earnest, a way of naming what they are trying to do without naming anything else. Opal reluctantly agrees, and the agreement shifts their dynamic. What was rivalry and avoidance becomes something they are doing together, a shared task with rules and a clock, and the shift is real even if neither of them names it. The escape room is a container for whatever is between them, a place where they can be on the same side without having to talk about why that is complicated. They are practicing being friends, and the practice is awkward and real, and it changes the shape of the thing between them.

The Question He Won't Drop

Will wants to know Opal's sexual history. The wanting is not casual. It is persistent, a subject he will not let go of. He presses her with guesses, and the pressure makes her defensive and uncomfortable. He does not let the subject go, and she is put on the back foot, guarding something he keeps trying to pry open. The questions are invasive, and the invasiveness is the point, or at least it is the effect. She does not want to answer, and he does not want to stop asking, and the whole exchange leaves her guarded and him unsatisfied, the subject hanging between them like something neither of them can put down.

The Provocation

Will wants to provoke Opal, and he suggests he could understand her needs better than Banks. The suggestion unsettles her with its intensity. It is not a casual remark. It lands with weight, and she feels the force of it, the implication hanging between them. The provocation is deliberate, and it works, because it touches something she does not want touched. The comparison to Banks is not the point. The point is the claim, the idea that Will could understand her in a way someone else cannot, and the claim sits with her after the words are gone.

The Key Under the Clock

Opal wants to win the escape room with the group. The wanting is simple and competitive, a goal with clear rules. The clock is running down, and she finds the hidden key under the clock, saving them at the last second. The win is hers in the final moment, the pressure breaking just as it seems they will fail. The key is under the clock, and the clock is the thing that was going to defeat them, and she finds it just in time. The win is a relief and a triumph, and it belongs to her, the moment when everything could have gone wrong going right instead.

The Hug That Changes

Opal wants to celebrate the escape room win, and she hugs Will. The hug is meant to be a celebration, the natural expression of a shared victory. But the embrace becomes charged, and they pull apart awkwardly. The celebration turns into something neither of them planned, the contact carrying more than congratulation. The hug is not just a hug. It is the thing that changes the temperature of the room, that makes the win into something else, that leaves them both aware of something they did not intend to reveal.

The Interruption

Will wants to acknowledge the moment between them. The wanting is visible, the way he retreats after being interrupted, the way both of them are left confused. Whatever was about to be said goes unsaid, and the confusion settles over them both. The interruption is not a resolution. It is a pause, a moment when something almost happened and then did not, and the not-happening is its own kind of event, leaving them with the shape of what might have been said.

The Walk Back

Opal wants to ignore her feelings for Will after the escape room. The ignoring is a decision, a way of putting the charged moment behind her. But on the walk back to the hotel she is hyperaware of every brush of contact. She cannot will the feelings away, and the walk becomes a gauntlet of small touches, each one reminding her of what she is trying to deny. The walk is not long, but it is long enough for every accidental touch to register, for every brush of arm against arm to become something she cannot ignore. She wanted to ignore her feelings. The walk makes that impossible.

Will asks Opal on a second date, putting himself out there despite the awkwardness that still hangs over their intense moment, and she agrees. The asking is a risk, and the agreeing is a risk, and both of them take it. When the evening ends, he hesitates at her door, clearly wanting to say something more, but instead retreats with a simple "Good night," leaving Opal unsettled by everything left unspoken. The hesitation at the door is the thing she remembers, the way he almost said something and then did not, the way the good night was not just a good night but a door closing on something that might have been opened.

Opal resolves to bury her guilt and move past the moment, deciding that Will never has to know. The resolution is a decision to keep something from him, to carry the guilt alone rather than share it. She turns to real estate listings, wanting to move out, and in the process recognizes that Will is the reason she has stayed so long. The recognition is not welcome. It is the kind of thing that arrives unbidden, that changes the meaning of everything that came before. She has stayed because of him, and the knowing of that is its own kind of guilt, its own kind of complication.

Will texts her asking her to grab cheese at Greg's on her way home, and the casual use of the word "home" for the apartment unsettles her. The word is small, but it carries weight, the assumption that the apartment is home, that she is coming home, that they share something that can be called home. Opal replies that she is already home, a deliberate move to make Will uncomfortable while he wonders what she might have heard. The reply is a small act of aggression, a way of putting him on the back foot, of making him wonder. He comes to her doorway, embarrassed and fishing for how long she has been there, and Opal lets him squirm without revealing anything. The squirming is the point, or at least it is a kind of satisfaction, the pleasure of watching him wonder, of holding something over him without confirming or denying. Then Will invites her to share the pizza he is making, and though she does not want to interrupt his date, her hunger overpowers her reluctance. The invitation is ordinary, and the acceptance is ordinary, and yet both of them are carrying something into the shared pizza, something that the ordinary moment does not quite cover.

You've reached the end of the free chapters

Never lose the plot

Chapter-by-chapter summaries, characters and endings explained, and a book you can ask anything.

$0.00 due today · 7 days free, then $89.99/year ($7.49/mo) · Cancel anytime before day 7

plus sales tax where applicable

About the Author

Kiersten Modglin

Kiersten Modglin is a USA Today bestselling author known for writing psychological thrillers and suspense novels, including The Arrangement series, The Family Secret, and The Missing. She has independently published dozens of books and built a dedicated readership through her fast-paced, twist-driven storytelling. A Tennessee native, she writes full-time and has become a prominent figure in the indie thriller community.

Frequently Asked Questions about Head Under Water

What is Head Under Water about?
Opal returns to the small town she left seven years earlier, drawn back by family, grief, and a past she has spent years trying not to revisit. Taking a third-grade teaching job at her old elementary school puts her in daily proximity to Will, the person from her history she would rather keep at arm's length, while a new man named Banks seems to offer something like a fresh start. As the story moves between Opal's college years and the present, a string of unsettling accidents begins to look less like coincidence, and Opal starts to suspect someone may be targeting the people she loves. The stakes are her safety, her relationships, and the truth about a past that refuses to stay buried.
Who is the author of Head Under Water?
Kiersten Modglin is the author of this novel, a suspense-driven story built around secrets, complicated relationships, and steadily mounting dread. Her writing leans into psychological tension, shifting timelines, and the sense that danger is often closest to home.
Is Head Under Water worth reading?
It's a gripping read for anyone who likes psychological suspense that keeps the tension tight while also taking its characters' emotional lives seriously. Opal is a genuinely complicated protagonist, and the dual timeline between her college years and her present gives every relationship an extra charge. The pacing rewards readers who like to keep turning pages late into the night.
What are the main themes in Head Under Water?
Water and drowning recur throughout as a metaphor for grief, memory, and the feeling of being pulled under by forces outside your control. The novel explores how the past keeps resurfacing no matter how far you run from it, and how old wounds shape the way you love and trust. Grief and caretaking run alongside it, especially the tension between the need to protect the people you love and their right to live on their own terms. Suspicion is another thread, as the characters wrestle with how well we can ever really know the people closest to us.
0

Never lose the plot

Chapter-by-chapter summaries, characters and endings explained, and a book you can ask anything.