Head Under Water Themes
by Kiersten Modglin

Underneath its plot, Head Under Water is really wrestling with grief and absence, especially the fear of losing family after Ruth's death, and with how love and hate get tangled in Opal and Will's rivalry, teasing, and long-hidden devotion.
Here you'll find each theme tied to moments: grief and fear of losing family after Ruth's death; Opal and Will's love-hate rivalry, jealousy, and hidden devotion; secrets surfacing through Ruth's death investigation; chosen family through Opal's mother, Ruth, and Margie; and healing after attacks and near-losses. Symbols include water and the bathtub, the blue truck, Ruth's gold heart necklace, and the secret anniversary gifts.
Major Themes in Head Under Water
Grief, Absence, and the Fear of Losing Family
The story repeatedly measures loss through the women who raised Opal and the family network around them. Ruth's death leaves an absence that drives both grief and suspicion, while Margie's hospitalization makes the possibility of another loss immediate.
- Opal blows a kiss toward Ruth's grave and notices Ruth's pink house looks empty and lifeless; she thinks she will never hear Ruth laugh again.
- When Margie is found unconscious, Opal thinks Ruth is gone and that if Margie dies, Mom will be all they have left; she also thinks the boys were never supposed to lose two moms.
- Margie tells Opal that Ruth loved her and considered her the daughter she never had.
Love and Hate Intertwined
Opal and Will's relationship is built through rivalry, teasing, jealousy, and long-hidden devotion. The novel keeps returning to the idea that their hostility has often been a cover for care, fear, and desire.
- Will says he can't stand Opal and yet would kill someone for hurting her, and that he can't stop wanting her.
- Will explains his past mistreatment of Opal, including incidents at the science fair and Gabe's party, as attempts to protect her from embarrassment or harm.
- Opal realizes that saying yes to Cory would mean saying no to Will, and she cannot lock that door even if she cannot open it yet.
- Will admits he gave Opal gifts every year since childhood because he wanted her to be okay, and says he would have waited fifty years.
Secrecy, Hidden Histories, and Their Consequences
The plot turns on information withheld by mothers, family friends, and the people closest to Opal. Ruth's death investigation exposes hidden relationships and old betrayals that eventually erupt into violence.
- Will reveals Ruth's death investigation is still open and that Betty and Margie have been questioned; Opal realizes her mother did not tell her.
- Will tells Opal that Ruth drowned in the bathtub after drinking and that police mentioned a sleeping pill, leaving open accident, self-inflicted, or intentional possibilities.
- Mom calls the investigation into Ruth's death hogwash and avoids the topic, later confessing that she was the woman George had an affair with.
- Banks reveals he is Ruth's son and George's son, says he pushed Margie, and declares he will kill the people Mom cares about.
Chosen Family and Caretaking
The novel presents family as something made through care, presence, and shared history rather than only blood. Opal's mother, Ruth, and Margie form a network of mothers around the children, and crisis brings the group together at hospitals and homes.
- Mom tells Opal she had three mothers, and lists Margie taking her to doctor's appointments, shopping for junior prom, and teaching her to parallel park.
- At the hospital, Mom explains that only immediate family can see Margie in the ICU, while Opal seeks comfort in her childhood home and offers to cook for the family.
- Opal and Mom look through Margie's photo album, recalling cookouts, Halloween, school photos, and childhood moments together; Mom says love can be friendship and that she had all the love she could ask for from 'you kids. My girls.'
Healing, Trust, and Moving Forward
After secrets, attacks, and near-losses, the story moves toward the possibility of healing without erasing grief. Opal's growth is shown in her choice to trust Will and to imagine a future after trauma.
- Opal spirals into doubts about Will but resolves, 'I will not run. I'm going to trust him.'
- Three months after Banks attacks her, Opal reflects that her old self might have run but that girl feels distant; she says time fixes most things, but it will not bring Ruth back.
- Opal tells Will she loves him and apologizes for taking so long; Will says he would have waited and kisses her.
Symbols and Motifs
Water and the Bathtub
Water is the recurring site of violence, death, and near-drowning in the story. The bathtub links Ruth's death to the attacks on Opal and makes water feel like a place where danger and buried truth surface.
- In the opening, a shadowed attacker holds Opal underwater in a bathtub and nearly drowns her.
- Will tells Opal that Ruth drowned in the bathtub after drinking and that police mentioned a sleeping pill.
- Opal returns home exhausted after the hospital and takes a lavender bath before Banks attacks her in the bathtub and tries to drown her.
The Blue Truck
The blue truck functions as a motif of looming threat, suspicion, and unresolved danger. It appears around Ruth's death and later around Opal, connecting the investigation to the fear that someone is watching the family.
- Cory reported seeing a blue truck at Ruth's about a week before; Ruth claimed it was a washing-machine piece, but police found no packaging and suspected she might have been seeing someone.
- Opal wakes to knocking, sees a blue truck idling in the driveway, cannot see the driver, locks the back door, and the truck leaves.
- Opal tells Mom about the blue truck at school and at Mom's house, says she suspects George has been following her, and wants to go to the police.
Ruth's Gold Heart Necklace
Ruth's necklace represents maternal love, memory, and legacy. Giving it to Opal confirms Ruth's place as one of Opal's mothers and makes Opal part of Ruth's living history.
- Mom gives Opal a black box containing Ruth's gold heart necklace, saying Ruth would want her to have it.
- Margie says Opal was the daughter Ruth never had and that Ruth loved her.
The Secret Anniversary Gifts
The gifts become a symbol of Will's quiet, patient devotion. They show that he has been paying attention to Opal and caring for her long before either of them could admit it.
- On the anniversary of her dad's death, Opal receives Sour Skittles, a stuffed rabbit, and a bracelet at her dorm and assumes Banks sent them.
- Mom admits Will was the one who gave the anniversary gifts all along and that she let Opal believe they were from her.
- Will explains he began giving Opal gifts as a child, first flowers from the yard and later with chore money, because he wanted her to be okay.