Head Under Water Book Club Questions
by Kiersten Modglin

These questions assume everyone has finished the book and contain spoilers, including the ending.
Head Under Water gives a book club plenty to unpack: old rivalries, small-town secrets, unreliable memories, and the uneasy feeling that everyone knows more than they are saying. The story keeps shifting what you think about its characters, which makes it easy to debate motive, trust, and blame.
Use these questions as a loose guide rather than a script. Pick a few that match your group's energy, give everyone a minute to jot down reactions, then let the conversation follow the tensions that surface. They work well for both in-person and online discussions.
Characters and Choices
- 1.What did you make of Opal deliberately scuffing Will's refinished stairs after he warns her not to damage them? Is it petty revenge, a way to assert control, or something else?
- 2.Professor Gene pairs Opal and Will and later praises them as 'star student volunteers,' while Will quits the volunteer program after his knuckles are scabbed and Banks has a bruised eye. Did you believe Will's explanation or lack of denial about punching Banks? What did that choice reveal about his character?
- 3.Cory asks Will's permission before asking Opal out, and Mom warns Opal that Cory's messy divorce and custody issues could entangle her. How did you view Cory's motives and Opal's hesitation—did you think Cory was genuinely interested, or was he also trying to push Will?
- 4.Will explains that his childhood bullying of Opal—knocking over her science fair volcano, spilling her drink at Gabe's party, and other incidents—was meant to protect her from embarrassment or harm. Did this explanation make you reevaluate Will, or did it feel like a retroactive excuse?
- 5.Will admits he secretly gave Opal anniversary gifts for years, first flowers from the yard and later with chore money, and says he would have waited for her. Did this confession feel earned given their history, or did it change how you saw his earlier teasing and 'fake friend' arrangement?
Rivalry and Romance
- 6.Opal returns to town after seven years and ends up staying at Will's apartment because their mothers arranged it. How does the forced proximity in Chapters 1–6 reshape the childhood rivalry between Opal and Will, especially after Will reveals Ruth's investigation is still open?
- 7.Will claims he waited for Opal the night of the conference and later says he was alone, while Opal had assumed he was with another woman. How does this misreading shape their relationship, and who else in the novel misreads a situation in a damaging way?
- 8.At the bonfire, Opal kisses Paul while watching Will, then enters the barn game and recognizes Will by his cologne. Did you agree with Opal's choice to say yes to Will in the dark? What did that scene reveal about desire, anonymity, and the rules Opal and Will had been playing?
Family Secrets and Suspicion
- 9.The anonymous text 'What did we do?' and Mom's dismissal of the investigation as 'hogwash' create early suspicion around the three mothers. How did Mom's secrecy about Ruth's death affect your trust in her, especially once she later confesses her affair with George?
- 10.The blue truck appears at Ruth's house, follows Opal, and is connected to George. How did the blue truck function as a clue, and did the reveal that George was Ruth's ex-husband and Mom's affair partner make the danger feel more or less plausible to you?
- 11.Mom tells Opal she had three mothers, including Margie and Ruth. How does the novel use the 'three mothers' idea—Ruth, Margie, and Betty—to explore chosen family, and how does Ruth's secret son change the way you read that family?
- 12.After Margie's fall and surgery, Opal suspects someone is targeting Ruth, Margie, and Mom, while Mom insists the accidents are unrelated. Whose reading of events did you find more convincing at that point, and why?
- 13.Mom's confession that she was the woman George had an affair with—and that she never told Ruth—rewrites Opal's understanding of her family. How did that revelation affect your view of Mom, Ruth, and George, and did it change who you suspected of harming Ruth?
Revelations and the Aftermath
- 14.Banks is revealed as Ruth's son and George's son, and he attacks Opal in the bathtub while blaming Mom for ruining his family. Looking back, which earlier details about Banks—his interest in Opal, his stories about Clinton, or his interactions with Will—felt most suspicious once the truth came out?
- 15.At the end, Banks is out on bail awaiting trial, George has not agreed to testify, and Opal reflects that she and Will are Ruth's 'living, breathing history.' Did you find the ending hopeful, unsettling, or both? What did you think of Opal's choice to stay with Will and forgive Mom?