Head Under Water Characters
by Kiersten Modglin

This is an ensemble cast full of small-town history, family ties, and people who know more than they let on. Opal anchors the story as a grieving teacher who comes home, stays with Will, and starts pulling at the loose threads around Ruth's death, while old crushes, childhood rivals, and the three mothers' circle keep complicating everything.
On this page you'll find each character's role, description, relationships, and story arc, from Will and Banks to Betty, Margie, Cory, and the smaller figures around Opal. It's a spoiler-conscious guide to who's connected to whom and how those connections shape the mystery.
Main Characters
Opal
ProtagonistThe central protagonist, a third-grade teacher who returns to her hometown after seven years and stays temporarily in Will's spare room. She is grieving Ruth, suspicious about Ruth's death, and caught between her childhood rivalry with Will and her growing feelings for him. She is also a former Havenport college student who reconnects with Banks and later learns his true identity.
Arc: She moves from resisting Will and trying to escape her hometown to admitting her love for him and confronting the truth about Ruth, her mother, and Banks. After surviving Banks's attack, she begins to heal, accepts Ruth's necklace, and chooses a future with Will and her family.
- Will — childhood nemesis, temporary roommate, and eventual love interest
- Betty — her mother
- Ruth — second mother figure
- Margie — family friend and mother figure
- Cory — childhood neighbor and friend who later asks her out
- Banks — college crush and former romantic interest who later attacks her
- Jess — college roommate and friend
- George — school colleague and suspect
- Professor Gene — her statistics professor
- Richie — Will's nephew and Cory's son, whom she learns about
Banks
AntagonistA former college crush and later romantic interest of Opal's who reappears as a teacher and dates her. He is revealed to be Ruth's son and George's son, and he blames Betty for ruining his family. He attacks Opal in the bathtub and claims he pushed Margie.
Arc: He moves from charming suitor to Ruth's vengeful son, attacking Opal and declaring he will kill the people Betty cares about. He is subdued by Will and Opal, arrested, and later out on bail awaiting trial.
- Opal — former college crush and romantic interest whom he attacks
- Ruth — his mother
- George — his father
- Betty — blames her for ruining his family
- Will — fights and is subdued by him
- Margie — admits pushing her
Supporting Characters
Will
SupportingOpal's childhood nemesis and eventual love interest, Margie's son and Cory's brother. He offers Opal a spare room, teases and competes with her, and later reveals a long-hidden protective and romantic interest in her. He is also Opal's college volunteer partner and a caretaker for his nephew Richie.
Arc: He shifts from antagonistic teasing and pretending friendship to admitting he has cared about Opal since childhood, saving her from Banks, and openly loving her. He remains protective of his family and quietly devoted to Opal.
- Opal — childhood nemesis, roommate, and love interest
- Margie — his mother
- Cory — his brother
- Richie — his nephew
- Betty — family friend who treats him like a son
- Banks — rival whom he fights and restrains
- Professor Gene — his statistics professor
Betty
SupportingOpal's mother, called Mom in the notes, who wants Opal to have a safe place and tends to avoid confronting painful problems. She is best friends with Ruth and Margie and later confesses to an affair with George. She is also close to Will and Cory and treats them like family.
Arc: She initially hides the investigation and the sleeping pill from Opal, then reveals Ruth's marriage and her own affair. After Banks's attack, she tries to repair her relationship with Opal and gives her Ruth's necklace.
- Opal — her daughter
- Ruth — best friend
- Margie — best friend
- George — man she had an affair with
- Will — family friend she treats like a son
- Cory — family friend she treats like a son
- Banks — blames her for his family's ruin
Ruth
SupportingOpal's second mother figure and Betty and Margie's best friend, whose recent death is under investigation. She drowned in the bathtub after drinking, with a sleeping pill involved, and her past marriage and son are revealed later. Her secret marriage, lost custody, and final meeting with her son drive much of the mystery.
Arc: She is dead before the present but drives the mystery through the investigation and her hidden history. Her legacy concludes with Opal receiving her necklace and learning Ruth loved her like a daughter.
- Opal — second mother figure
- Betty — best friend
- Margie — best friend
- Banks — her son
- George — her ex-husband
Margie
SupportingWill and Cory's mother and a family friend to Opal, one of the three mothers in Opal's childhood circle. She arranges Opal's room with Will and is later found unconscious after a fall. She is hospitalized with a subdural hematoma and later recovers at a facility.
Arc: She is hospitalized after Banks pushes her and remains sedated for a time. She later recovers enough to sit, stand, and speak, and she affirms Ruth's love for Opal.
- Will — her son
- Cory — her son
- Betty — best friend
- Ruth — best friend
- Opal — family friend and mother figure
Cory
SupportingWill's brother, Margie's son, and Richie's father, as well as a childhood friend of Opal's. He has joint custody concerns involving Miranda, asks Opal out, and supports the family during Margie's hospitalization. He often hides distress with humor.
Arc: He moves from a possible romantic interest for Opal to accepting her relationship with Will and teasing them. He remains a steady family presence during Margie's hospitalization and recovery.
- Will — his brother
- Margie — his mother
- Richie — his son
- Miranda — custody concern
- Opal — friend who asks her out
- Betty — family friend
George
SupportingA gym teacher and coach at Opal's school, revealed to be Ruth's ex-husband and the man Betty had an affair with. Opal suspects his blue truck has been following her, though Betty insists he was not violent. He is also Banks's father.
Arc: He shifts from friendly colleague to suspect, then is partly clarified when Banks says George learned of his plan and called Betty. George posts Banks's bail but has not agreed to testify.
- Ruth — his ex-wife
- Betty — affair partner
- Banks — his son, whose bail he posted
- Opal — school colleague and suspect
Jess
SupportingOpal's college roommate and friend, who introduces Opal to King, hooks up with Will at a party, and later encourages Opal to have fun. She remains a supportive friend through college scenes.
Arc: She moves through college friendships and parties, urging Opal out of her comfort zone, and later helps Opal get ready for her date.
- Opal — college roommate and friend
- Will — hooks up with him at a party
- King — introduces him to Opal
Professor Gene
SupportingOpal and Will's statistics professor in college flashbacks, who pairs them as class volunteers and later sends them to a conference. He praises them as star volunteers and later tells Opal that Will quit the program.
Arc: He serves as the institutional force pairing Opal and Will, then leaves Opal to present alone after Will quits.
- Opal — her statistics professor
- Will — his statistics professor
Richie
SupportingCory's seven-year-old son and Will's nephew, called Richard by Will. He is discussed in connection with Cory's custody fears and Margie's hospitalization.
Arc: He remains mostly off-page but is a motivating family concern for Cory and Will during the hospital crisis.
- Cory — his father
- Will — his uncle
- Miranda — named in custody concerns
- Margie — family member discussed in the hospital context
Miranda
SupportingA named figure connected to Cory's joint custody of Richie. Cory fears she will find a reason to take custody away.
Arc: She remains off-page, a source of custody anxiety for Cory.
- Cory — named in connection with joint custody
- Richie — named in connection with custody
Paul
SupportingA classmate from Intro to Psych who kisses Opal at the bonfire, explains Strangers in the Dark, and invites her to play. He says he does not mind being used to make Will jealous if it means spending time with Opal.
Arc: He serves as a catalyst for Opal's jealousy game and the anonymous barn encounter with Will.
- Opal — party acquaintance whom he kisses at the bonfire and invites into the game
- Will — used to make him jealous
King
SupportingA party acquaintance Jess introduces to Opal. He dances with Opal after Jess tells him she is hot.
Arc: He is a brief party presence with no further plot role.
- Opal — dances with her at the party
- Jess — introduces him to Opal
Mrs. Broccoli
SupportingThe elementary school office secretary who welcomes Opal and shows her to her classroom. She mentions Connie's retirement and is excited that Opal has come home to teach.
Arc: She is a minor welcoming presence at Opal's new job.
- Opal — school secretary who welcomes her