What We Found Instead Themes

by Heidi Reimer

What We Found Instead by Heidi Reimer Book Cover
This analysis draws on moments from across the whole book and may contain spoilers.

Underneath its plot, What We Found Instead is really about how deception and grief reshape people, and how women who start as rivals can become something like chosen family. Karl's compartmentalized double life, Maggie's ectopic pregnancy and lost baby, Violet's death, and both women's collapsed futures keep raising questions about trust, proof, confession, and what happens when imagined futures fall apart.

On this page you'll find theme analysis of deception and betrayal, grief and loss, female rivalry and chosen family, healing and reinvention, motherhood and bodily vulnerability, and truth and secrecy, with concrete moments like Eve's return to Still Lake and her transformation of Bernice's lodge. It also traces recurring symbols: Truth Landing, Still Lake's water, Flora the dog, and Maggie's scar.

Major Themes in What We Found Instead

Deception, Betrayal, and the Double Life

Karl’s relationships with Maggie and Eve are built on compartmentalization and false explanations: he tells Maggie he is helping his parents while spending weekends at Eve’s cabin, and he lets Eve believe he is her partner while having a girlfriend in Toronto. The novel ties this deception to damaged trust, as both women search phones, demand proof, and later conceal truths from each other and from Karl.

  • Maggie guesses Karl’s passcode, hears Eve’s voicemail about fixing his sandal, and finds Eve’s calls and emails, including a pet-store message about Flora’s new bed.
  • Maggie says Karl lives in Toronto and is only up north on weekends, while Eve says he lives up north and is only in Toronto for work.
  • Charmaine says Karl’s secret juggling of both women would take high-level strategy or compartmentalization or self-deception.
  • Eve later tells Karl that he got Maggie pregnant too and mentions his expired condoms.

Grief and Loss

Grief runs through Violet’s death, Maggie’s ectopic pregnancy and lost baby, and the collapse of both women’s imagined futures with Karl. The notes show grief as nonhierarchical and sometimes ambiguous, including grieving a baby never had and mourning a relationship that was partly fantasy.

  • Maggie and Daniel use a grief scale, and Maggie asks whether she can grieve the loss of a baby she never had; Daniel answers, 'Yes.'
  • Daniel tells Eve, 'You can’t judge somebody’s grief. There isn’t a hierarchy.'
  • Maggie studies her bruised abdomen and stapled incision and later says she feels as if her life has ended and she is waiting for a new one.
  • Eve dreams that Violet is alive and then killed by an SUV, and Daniel says every day without Violet has been torture.

Female Rivalry, Care, and Chosen Family

Maggie and Eve begin as rivals over Karl, with Maggie hoping for 'woman to woman' commiseration while Eve is hostile, but their relationship shifts through reluctant care, shared grief, and practical support. The novel contrasts isolation and resentment with partnership, co-parenting, and a community of women caring for women.

  • Eve declares that she and Maggie aren’t friends and leaves, but the next morning she apologizes, refuses Maggie’s offer to pay, and invites Maggie to stay at the lodge.
  • Eve washes Maggie’s blood-stained pants, moves her to the fishing lodge, researches ectopic rupture, and checks Maggie’s breathing.
  • Maggie helps Eve with prenatal vitamins, groceries, laundry, lotion, and gentle yoga after Eve says she is keeping the baby.
  • Eve asks Maggie to be 'Mama Maggie' and co-parent Lizzie, and eight years later they are described as platonic soulmates and co-parents.

Healing, Reinvention, and Rebuilding

Both women try to remake themselves and their surroundings after betrayal and loss: Eve returns to Still Lake and later transforms Bernice’s lodge, while Maggie moves from crisis and drift toward a concrete retreat-center plan. Renovation work and the retreat center give physical form to emotional repair.

  • Eve leaves New York by train, buys a truck and Flora, drives back to Still Lake, and breathes air she says she has not breathed since age thirteen.
  • Maggie visualizes her feelings for Karl on flaming arrows shot into Still Lake.
  • Maggie and Eve smash out the rotting dining hall floor while chanting 'Karl! Cheaters! Deadbeats!' and Maggie films it for the retreat center Instagram.
  • Maggie writes a retreat-center business plan, tells her father she will not complete her Ph.D., and the book ends at the fifth-anniversary party for the Truth Landing Wilderness Retreat Center.

Motherhood, Pregnancy, and Bodily Vulnerability

Pregnancy is both a source of hope and a site of fear, loss, and bodily alienation. Maggie’s ectopic pregnancy and Eve’s pregnancy with Karl’s child force questions about single motherhood, co-parenting, and whether their bodies and futures are their own.

  • Maggie thinks of the pregnancy test as her breakup ritual and plans to use Natalie’s stockpile under the bathroom sink.
  • Five days after a positive pregnancy test, Maggie tries to reach Karl, and she later collapses on the bathroom floor bleeding and vomiting.
  • Eve stares at the positive pregnancy test and imagines either calling the number on the notepad or carrying the pregnancy to term, then asks Daniel whether she could be a good mom.
  • Karl says Eve’s pregnant body seems taken over by 'an alien' and that the baby moving during sex is 'weird. Indecent, almost'; Eve replies, 'This body is me.'

Truth, Secrecy, and Trust

The characters constantly negotiate what to reveal and what to hide, and trust is tied to proof, confession, and timing. Even after Karl’s deception is exposed, Maggie and Eve keep their own secrets—about Daniel, pregnancy, and the lost baby—until truth-telling becomes part of repair.

  • Eve deletes Maggie’s warning email after debating whether to trust a stranger.
  • Eve demands facts and views dated photos of Karl and Maggie before accepting that Karl and Maggie had a relationship.
  • Maggie texts Daniel that she will tell Eve today, while Eve keeps her possible pregnancy secret until Maggie guesses it.
  • Maggie withholds the truth about her lost baby from Karl, and Eve later reveals to Karl that he got Maggie pregnant too.

Symbols and Motifs

Truth Landing

A name and painting that represent truth arriving, being turned toward or away from, and eventually being reclaimed as a place of refuge and community.

  • Eve finds a painting labeled 'Truth Landing' at Bernice’s fishing lodge, says 'Truth has landed, all right,' and turns the painting back around.
  • Eve later nails the Truth Landing painting over the bed in the lodge room she prepares for Maggie.
  • Bernice explains that Truth Landing was the name of the spot where boats put in.
  • The retreat center is finally called the Truth Landing Wilderness Retreat Center.

Still Lake and lake water

The lake represents refuge, release, renewal, and emotional exposure; it is where Eve retreats, where both women swim and canoe, and where Maggie imagines releasing her attachment to Karl.

  • Eve loves her house as 'enclosed. Guarded. Safe.' and goes canoeing to escape 'the type of stress Maggie Dunn had lobbed at her.'
  • After breaking up with Karl, Eve walks to the lake, undresses, and plunges into the cold water with Flora.
  • Maggie visualizes placing her feelings for Karl on flaming arrows and shooting them into Still Lake.
  • Maggie swims alone after Daniel refuses, and Eve confronts her in the water.

Flora the dog

Flora symbolizes loyalty, comfort, and a bridge of care between Eve and Maggie; her injuries and recovery also mirror vulnerability and survival.

  • Flora greets Karl at Eve’s cabin and later at the woodpile, and she barks urgently at the patio door until Eve finds Maggie collapsed on the deck.
  • Flora stays at the foot of Maggie’s bed at the fishing lodge, and Eve says Flora wants to stay with Maggie.
  • A tree crashes through the dining hall roof and pins Flora under a branch, breaking her right hind leg.
  • Eight years later, Flora stands in the center of the dance circle at the retreat center anniversary party.

Maggie’s scar

Maggie’s scar is a visible mark of loss and bodily vulnerability, and showing it becomes an act of trust and evidence of healing.

  • Maggie inspects her bruised abdomen and stapled incision in the bathroom after her ectopic pregnancy and surgery.
  • In the sauna Maggie shows Eve her post-surgery scar and says Eve is the first non-medical person to see it.
  • Daniel is gentle when he sees Maggie’s scar.
  • Maggie says she only looked at the scar without crying the day before.

Continue Exploring