What We Found Instead Characters
by Heidi Reimer

This novel has a big, interconnected cast built around two protagonists, Maggie and Eve, whose separate lives start to overlap through Karl. Around them are families, friends, roommates, coworkers, neighbors, and a few people from the lake and town who each add texture to the story.
On this page you will find every character's role, a short description, their key relationships, and the arcs that connect them. It is meant as a quick guide for keeping track of who is who as the two women's worlds move closer together.
Main Characters
Maggie Dunn
ProtagonistMaggie is Karl's girlfriend of nine months in Toronto who discovers his voicemail from Eve and investigates his double life. She meets Eve, learns she is the other woman, later becomes pregnant and suffers an ectopic pregnancy and ruptured fallopian tube. She is determined, grieving, and increasingly drawn to Eve's plan for a women's retreat center.
Arc: Maggie moves from uncovering Karl's deception and trying to end the relationship to recovering at Eve's home, helping imagine Truth Landing, and building a new life. After a rushed marriage to Daniel, she leaves him, returns to Eve with a retreat-center business plan, and becomes Mama Maggie and co-parent to Lizzie.
- Karl Tarvudd — her boyfriend of nine months, who deceived her and also impregnated Eve
- Eve Moretti — former rival over Karl, then friend, business partner, and co-parent
- Daniel — Eve's twin brother, her husband after a rushed New York marriage, later left by Maggie
- Charmaine — her best friend and confidante
- Sophie Dunn — her mother
- Natalie — her roommate
- Sarita — her roommate
- Flora — Eve's dog, who comforts her and stays with her
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — Eve's daughter, whom Maggie co-parents as Mama Maggie
- Daddy-O — her father
Eve Moretti
ProtagonistEve lives at Still Lake, is Daniel's twin sister, and had been Karl's partner for two years when Maggie contacts her. She is guarded, values safety and isolation, and works with wood and later at Labelle's Cabins. She becomes pregnant by Karl, buys Bernice's lodge, and imagines a women's retreat center.
Arc: Eve moves from wanting to keep Maggie out of her life to reluctantly caring for her, forming a friendship, and choosing Maggie over Karl. She gives birth to Lizzie, co-parents with Maggie, and helps build the Truth Landing Wilderness Retreat Center.
- Karl Tarvudd — her ex-partner and the father of her baby
- Maggie Dunn — former rival, then friend, business partner, and co-parent
- Daniel — her twin brother
- Flora — her chocolate lab
- Violet — her sister-in-law
- Sam Labelle — her father's best friend and employer at Labelle's Cabins
- Bernice — her neighbor and the seller of the lodge
- Mrs. Tarvudd — Karl's mother, who dislikes her
- Abby — her midwife
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — her daughter
Karl Tarvudd
AntagonistKarl is an adventure guide and bank employee who juggles two relationships: Eve at Still Lake and Maggie in Toronto. He is the father of Eve's pregnancy and also impregnated Maggie, whose pregnancy was ectopic. He disappears to Patagonia, returns to apologize and co-parent, and later gives Eve an ultimatum.
Arc: Karl's double life collapses when Maggie and Eve meet; he quits the bank, moves, and goes to Patagonia. He returns wanting to be in his daughter's life and to reconcile with Eve, but Eve chooses Maggie and releases him; years later he has a new girlfriend and plans to take Lizzie to Peru.
- Eve Moretti — his girlfriend of two years and the mother of his daughter
- Maggie Dunn — his girlfriend of nine months, whom he also deceived and impregnated
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — his daughter
- Mrs. Tarvudd — his mother
- Mr. Tarvudd — his father
- Daniel — Eve's brother, who is antagonistic toward him
- Scott — his friend from high school
- Flora — Eve's dog, who greets him affectionately
Supporting Characters
Daniel
SupportingDaniel is Eve's twin brother and a doctor grieving the death of his wife Violet. He texts Maggie by wrong number, forms a connection with her, and later marries her in New York after she leaves Still Lake with him. He is depressed, conflicted, and repeatedly struggles to make room for Maggie in his grief.
Arc: Daniel moves from anger at Eve and secret texting with Maggie to a rushed marriage, then strains under Violet's memory and his own grief. He and Maggie separate when she leaves him; by the retreat center anniversary he has a new girlfriend and dances with Lizzie and Charmaine.
- Eve Moretti — his twin sister
- Violet — his deceased wife
- Maggie Dunn — his wife after a rushed New York marriage, later separated
- Renata — Violet's best friend and dinner host
- Ivan — his friend and Renata's husband
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — dances with her at the anniversary party
- Charmaine — dances with her at the anniversary party
Flora
SupportingFlora is Eve's chocolate lab, who greets Karl, rides in the canoe, and stays close to Eve. She alerts Eve to Maggie collapsed on the deck and later curls at Maggie's feet, comforting her. She is injured when a tree crashes through the dining hall and breaks her right hind leg.
Arc: Flora moves from Eve's companion to Maggie's comfort and is seriously injured during the ice storm. She heals and remains part of Eve and Maggie's life at the retreat center anniversary.
- Eve Moretti — her owner
- Maggie Dunn — the woman she alerts Eve to and comforts
- Karl Tarvudd — greets him affectionately
Charmaine
SupportingCharmaine is Maggie's best friend and former roommate, a mother who works and cares for her children. She worries about Maggie's choices, listens to her about Karl and Eve, and deduces Maggie's pregnancy at Sukha. She helps Maggie through her collapse and bleeding and later dances with Lizzie and Daniel.
Arc: Charmaine moves from warning Maggie about confronting Eve and making rash decisions to supporting her through pregnancy loss, separation from Karl, and new plans. She remains a steady friend into the retreat center years.
- Maggie Dunn — her best friend and confidante
- Daria — coworker at Sukha
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — dances with her at the anniversary party
- Daniel — dances with him at the anniversary party
Violet
SupportingViolet is Daniel's wife and Renata's best friend, an obstetrician who is killed while riding her bike by a distracted driver in an SUV. She appears in memories and in Eve's dream, and her death drives much of Daniel's grief. Her birthday dinner becomes a confrontation over Daniel's new marriage.
Arc: Violet is dead before the main events, but her memory shapes Daniel, Eve, Renata, and Maggie's relationships. She is progressively both a source of grief and a presence Daniel cannot erase.
- Daniel — her husband
- Eve Moretti — her sister-in-law
- Renata — her best friend
Sam Labelle
SupportingSam Labelle is Eve's father's best friend and her employer at Labelle's Cabins. He looks after Eve after her breakup, takes her for a dock picnic, and tells her she is a good soul after hearing the truth about Karl. He also inspects the lodge with Eve and Maggie and reveals rot and financial problems.
Arc: Sam moves from caretaking Eve as her employer and old family friend to helping her assess the lodge and later greeting Daniel as an old friend. He offers Daniel a job and jokes about Maggie poaching Eve for the competition.
- Eve Moretti — her employer and old family friend
- Maggie Dunn — gives her a ride and conducts the lodge inspection with her
- Daniel — old friend
- Bernice — neighbor who says Sam told her she can trust Eve
Bernice
SupportingBernice is Eve's neighbor who owns a fishing lodge near Still Lake. She gives Eve keys to watch the lodge while visiting her sister, later sells the lodge to Eve, and explains that Truth Landing was the name of the spot where boats put in. She hosts a goodbye dinner before moving.
Arc: Bernice moves from needing someone to watch her lodge to selling it to Eve and leaving for her sister's. She tells Maggie and Eve they will do well and reveals information about the Truth Landing painting.
- Eve Moretti — her neighbor and the buyer of her lodge
- Maggie Dunn — new acquaintance and potential buyer
- Sam Labelle — neighbor who says she can trust Eve
Mrs. Tarvudd
SupportingMrs. Tarvudd is Karl's mother, who is protective of him and hostile toward Eve. She refuses to confirm Karl's whereabouts, says Eve is no longer his girlfriend, advises no contact, and rolls her eyes when Eve asks for proof. She gives her husband a dirty look when he reveals Karl's location.
Arc: Mrs. Tarvudd remains cold and protective of Karl throughout, believing it is better not to get pulled back into something already decided against.
- Karl Tarvudd — her son
- Eve Moretti — Karl's ex-girlfriend, whom she dislikes
- Mr. Tarvudd — her husband
Mr. Tarvudd
SupportingMr. Tarvudd is Karl's father, who tells Eve that Karl is in Argentina or Chile on a Patagonia expedition and is off-grid. He shows her an email photograph of Karl in front of a mountain and grips her arm to ask if she is all right. He is more forthcoming than his wife.
Arc: Mr. Tarvudd briefly reveals Karl's location and shows concern for Eve, but otherwise remains a minor figure in Karl's family.
- Karl Tarvudd — his son
- Eve Moretti — his son's ex-girlfriend
- Mrs. Tarvudd — his wife
Sophie Dunn
SupportingSophie Dunn is Maggie's mother, who is compassionate but practical. She urges Maggie to focus on her work and the trust money and later refuses immediate access to the trust unless Maggie finishes her dissertation and talks to her father. She wants Maggie to move forward and have options.
Arc: Sophie remains a practical counterweight to Maggie's decisions, supporting her while pushing her toward work and financial responsibility.
- Maggie Dunn — her daughter
Natalie
SupportingNatalie is Maggie's roommate, who asks if she is okay and reacts with dismay when Maggie says she has to leave Karl. She keeps a stockpile of dollar-store pregnancy tests under the bathroom sink and brings Maggie clean clothes in the hospital. She is unavailable to escort Maggie home because she is writing exams.
Arc: Natalie remains a concerned roommate and friend; her pregnancy tests become part of Maggie's breakup ritual, and she later supports Maggie from a distance.
- Maggie Dunn — her roommate and friend; Maggie plans to use her pregnancy tests
Sarita
SupportingSarita is Maggie's roommate, who hands her a bowl of chili and hugs her while asking what happened. She wants to comfort Maggie after the revelation about Karl.
Arc: Sarita remains a minor but caring presence in Maggie's home life.
- Maggie Dunn — her roommate
Daria
SupportingDaria is Maggie's boss at Sukha, described as a coiled spring of stress and micromanagement. She answers when Maggie calls to quit, is consumed by work crises, and later shrieks into her phone for emergency help when Maggie collapses. She is not present for much of Maggie's ordeal but affects her work life.
Arc: Daria remains a stress-driven boss whose work demands continue until Maggie quits and collapses; she ends up calling emergency services.
- Maggie Dunn — her employee at Sukha
- Charmaine — coworker at the store
Xavier
SupportingXavier is Karl's colleague and bank manager, who recognizes Maggie at the bank and tells her Karl quit over a week ago and went north to his parents' place. He asks whether she is okay and seems concerned.
Arc: Xavier provides Maggie with the first clear information about Karl's disappearance, helping send her north.
- Karl Tarvudd — his colleague and bank manager
- Maggie Dunn — an acquaintance who knows him from a Christmas party
Renata
SupportingRenata is Violet's best friend, who hosts Violet's birthday dinner and greets Daniel weeping. She rejects Maggie's flowers because she is allergic to daisies and challenges Daniel sharply about moving on with Maggie. She is grieving and resentful of Daniel's new marriage.
Arc: Renata remains hostile toward Maggie and protective of Violet's memory, confronting Daniel at the dinner.
- Violet — her best friend
- Daniel — Violet's husband, toward whom she is hostile
- Ivan — her husband
- Maggie Dunn — hostile toward her
Ivan
SupportingIvan is Renata's husband and Daniel's friend, who hosts the Violet birthday dinner with Renata and gives Daniel a half-hearted congratulations after Maggie reveals the marriage. He is also with Daniel at the hospital after Violet's death and explains the accident to Eve by phone.
Arc: Ivan remains a supporting friend and host, caught between grief, Violet's friends, and Daniel's new marriage.
- Renata — his wife
- Daniel — his friend
- Eve Moretti — speaks to her by phone about Violet's accident
Aya
SupportingAya is one of Violet's friends and a dinner guest at Renata's, who assumes Maggie is with the cake and introduces herself. She says that anger is a stage of grief and tries to placate the table.
Arc: Aya remains a minor grieving friend who observes the conflict at Violet's birthday dinner.
- Violet — her next-best friend
- Renata — friend and host
Cicely
SupportingCicely is one of Violet's friends at the birthday dinner, who asks Maggie who she is and whether there was a wedding. She tells Daniel he was smitten with Violet and challenges him at dinner. She is loyal to Violet and skeptical of Daniel's new marriage.
Arc: Cicely remains a minor but pointed voice among Violet's friends, questioning Daniel and Maggie's marriage.
- Violet — her friend
- Daniel — challenges him at dinner
- Maggie Dunn — asks who she is at the dinner
Abby
SupportingAbby is Eve's midwife, who calls Eve into the midwife appointment and later guides Eve through labor. She arrives with paramedics, examines Eve and the baby, clamps the cord, and confirms Eve has a small first-degree tear. She brings tea and checks Lizzie's latch after the birth.
Arc: Abby moves from prenatal care to delivering Lizzie and supporting Eve and Maggie in the first hours after birth.
- Eve Moretti — her midwife
- Maggie Dunn — advises her by phone during labor
- Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie) — checks the baby's latch
Scott
SupportingScott is Karl's friend from high school, who visits Karl and Eve at the lodge and reminisces with Karl. He reacts enthusiastically when Karl describes the lodge as an outdoor adventure center, prompting Eve to confront Karl.
Arc: Scott remains a minor friend whose visit triggers Eve's discovery of Karl's improvised adventure-center plan.
- Karl Tarvudd — his friend from high school
- Eve Moretti — visits them at the lodge
Geoffrey Watts
SupportingGeoffrey Watts is a potential buyer who arrives for a second viewing of the lodge and says he and Linda want to make an offer contingent on an inspection. His visit is interrupted by Eve going into labor.
Arc: Geoffrey remains a prospective buyer whose offer is never completed because Eve chooses Maggie's plan instead.
- Linda Watts — his wife
- Eve Moretti — potential buyer of her lodge
Linda Watts
SupportingLinda Watts is a potential buyer who tours the lodge with Geoffrey and insists Eve come with them. She plans to knock down a dividing wall in Maggie's room to create a honeymoon suite and says their offer is contingent on an inspection.
Arc: Linda remains a prospective buyer until Eve goes into labor and later tells the Wattses the lodge is no longer for sale.
- Geoffrey Watts — her husband
- Eve Moretti — potential buyer who insists Eve tour with them
Elizabeth Violet Moretti (Lizzie)
SupportingElizabeth Violet Moretti, called Lizzie, is Eve's daughter, born in Maggie's room with Maggie's help and named after Violet. As a newborn she closes her fingers around Eve's pinky, and eight years later she is exuberant and incautious at the retreat center anniversary. She is co-parented by Eve and Maggie.
Arc: Lizzie moves from newborn to an eight-year-old who cuts her toe dancing barefoot, surprises her moms with a song, and pulls Maggie and Eve onto the dance floor.
- Eve Moretti — her mother
- Maggie Dunn — her co-parent and Mama Maggie
- Karl Tarvudd — her father
- Daniel — dances with him at the anniversary party
- Charmaine — dances with her at the anniversary party
George
SupportingGeorge is Eve's stepfather, who drove through the night with Eve's mother as soon as they heard about Violet's death. He is a minor but supportive presence in Eve's family.
Arc: George remains a background family figure whose main action is traveling to support Eve's family after Violet's death.
- Eve Moretti — her stepfather
Daddy-O
SupportingDaddy-O is Maggie's father, who listens to her business plan, pours tea, and validates her experience. He promises to read every word and prioritize her request, agrees that he loves her for herself, and treats her with directness. He is practical but open to seeing Maggie as she actually is.
Arc: Daddy-O moves from a distant parental figure to someone who hears Maggie's plan and accepts her account of their relationship, promising to consider her request seriously.
- Maggie Dunn — his daughter
Jenna
SupportingJenna is Maggie's co-worker at Sukha, who notices Maggie leaning against the doorframe and asks if she is okay. She later takes her break during Maggie's shift.
Arc: Jenna remains a minor co-worker who briefly notices Maggie's worsening condition before Maggie collapses.
- Maggie Dunn — co-worker at Sukha