What We Found Instead Book Club Questions
by Heidi Reimer

These questions assume everyone has finished the book and contain spoilers, including the ending.
This novel gives book clubs plenty to unpack: complicated relationships, secrets that surface in small details, and characters forced to decide what honesty and safety really mean to them. The story works best when readers talk through their mixed feelings rather than settling on easy judgments.
Use these questions to guide conversation, not control it. Pick a few that spark interest, give everyone time to reflect, and let the discussion move naturally. You can also pair related questions or return to one at the end to see how opinions shifted.
Suspicion, Deception, and Truth
- 1.Maggie cracks Karl's passcode, hears Eve's voicemail, and later confronts Eve at the Georgian Bay Travel Center. What did you think of her decision to investigate and meet Eve instead of confronting Karl directly?
- 2.Eve deletes Maggie's email and later demands proof from Maggie rather than trusting a stranger. How did you interpret Eve's need for facts before believing Karl was cheating, and did it fit her character?
- 3.Karl tells Maggie he is helping his parents but spends weekends at Eve's cabin. How does the novel use small details like the dog bed for Flora and the sandal voicemail to show his compartmentalized double life?
- 4.The novel returns repeatedly to truth and safety—from the "Truth Landing" painting to Eve's guarded house and Maggie's demand for an open mind from her father. Which character's relationship to truth changed the most, and why?
Care, Crisis, and Rivalry
- 5.After Maggie's ectopic pregnancy and ruptured fallopian tube, she travels to Eve's deck despite pain and bleeding. What does this journey reveal about Maggie's need for Karl, and how did it change your view of her?
- 6.Eve cares for Maggie despite resenting her as Karl's other girlfriend, washing her blood-stained pants and moving her to the fishing lodge. Why do you think Eve helps her, and what does this reluctant care reveal about Eve?
- 7.Maggie and Eve's canoeing, sauna, and Karl jar moments turn rivalry into friendship. Did you find their bond believable given how they met, and what specific scene best showed the shift?
Advice, Marriage, and Grief
- 8.Charmaine tells Maggie not to let Eve take over the dumping and later warns her against re-engaging with Karl. How useful was Charmaine's advice, and did Maggie follow or resist it?
- 9.Maggie and Daniel's wrong-number texts become a grief connection before they meet. Discuss how their parallel losses—Violet's death and Maggie's pregnancy loss—shape their relationship, and whether you saw their marriage as healing or avoidance.
- 10.At Renata's dinner for Violet's birthday, Daniel fails to introduce Maggie as his wife and calls the legal part of their marriage a technicality. Did you agree with Maggie's choice to leave Daniel after this humiliation?
Pregnancy, Desire, and Karl
- 11.Eve's pregnancy by Karl raises questions of co-parenting and honesty after he impregnated both women. Should Eve have told Karl sooner about the pregnancy, and how did you judge Maggie's choice to withhold the truth about her lost baby?
- 12.Karl says Eve's pregnant body seems "taken over by an alien" and calls the baby's movement during sex "weird. Indecent, almost"; Eve calls it misogyny. How does this scene comment on pregnancy, desire, and Karl's character?
The Ending and Chosen Family
- 13.Eve chooses Maggie over Karl during labor and asks Maggie to be "Mama Maggie" and co-parent Lizzie. What did you make of that choice, and how did it reframe the novel's central relationship?
- 14.The retreat center becomes a "magical community hub," and Eve and Maggie are described as platonic soulmates and co-parents. Is the ending's chosen-family resolution satisfying, or did you want more closure for Karl, Daniel, or Maggie's family?