What We Found Instead Ending Explained

by Heidi Reimer

Buy on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

What We Found Instead by Heidi Reimer Book Cover

If you finished What We Found Instead and felt like the ending left a few things hanging, you're not alone. This page walks through what literally happens at the end, why Heidi Reimer takes the story that way, and where each character lands. No spoilers yet, just a clear heads up about what's covered below.

Major spoiler warning: everything below reveals the full ending of What We Found Instead.

The Ending, Explained

Listen
0:000:00

What Happens at the End of What We Found Instead

Eve goes into active labor at the lodge. Maggie runs to Eve's house looking for Karl, calls Abby, gathers towels, a water bottle, a blanket and a duffel of baby clothes, and texts and phones Karl to tell him Eve is in labor. Back in Maggie's room, Eve is squatting and says she can feel the baby's head; Maggie helps her undress, washes her hands, checks, and although she does not yet see a head, Eve says she needs to push. Karl bursts in, insists Eve must go to the hospital, tries to dress her, says he will not be party to a home birth, and gives Eve an ultimatum to choose between him and Maggie. Eve, eyes closed and deep in labor, says she chooses Maggie and releases Karl; Karl stumbles over the baby duffel and leaves, and Maggie calls after him to call 911 and Abby.

After Karl leaves, Eve's labor accelerates. Her water breaks, she pushes on a towel-covered stool, and Maggie catches the baby as she emerges; the baby cries, Eve holds her skin to skin, and Abby and paramedics arrive. Abby clamps the cord, Maggie cuts it, and Abby confirms Eve has only a small first-degree tear. Eve names the baby Elizabeth Violet Moretti, called Lizzie. Eve then asks Maggie to be Mama Maggie and co-parent Lizzie, explaining that she has banished Karl as her co-parent; Maggie tearfully accepts, and both say they are ready to do this together.

Eight years later, in July, Maggie briefly leaves the fifth-anniversary party for the Truth Landing Wilderness Retreat Center to get a Band-Aid for Lizzie's cut toe. Eve and the aging Flora join her on the balcony. They talk about Daniel's toast, Daniel's new girlfriend, and Karl's new girlfriend, whom they did not invite; Karl is protective of Lizzie, lives in his parents' house, still travels with Vital Adventures, has Lizzie on weekends, and plans to take her to Peru for her ninth birthday. Eve mentions that Maggie's father is considering retiring nearby with Maggie's mother. They return to the party, where Lizzie pulls Maggie and Eve onto the dance floor into a circle with Flora in the center.

The Ending, Explained

The ending resolves the central triangle by making Eve choose Maggie not as a romantic partner but as the person who shows up, listens, and supports her in labor. Karl's final behavior is the payoff of earlier warnings: he is disgusted by Eve's pregnant body, tries to control the birth, and issues an ultimatum at the worst moment. Maggie, by contrast, acts without regard for her own complicated grief and jealousy: she runs for supplies, calls the midwife, coaches Eve, and catches the baby. Eve's choice of Maggie is therefore a judgment on Karl's version of love and a reward for Maggie's transformation from rival to caretaker and business partner. It also pays off the Truth Landing motif: the lodge and retreat center become a place of chosen family and renewal rather than isolation.

The birth also resolves Maggie's arc. She lost her ectopic pregnancy and feared she would not be a mother; Eve's request that she become Mama Maggie lets her mother Lizzie without erasing her loss. The ending does not pair Maggie and Eve romantically; instead it defines them as friends, business partners, platonic soulmates and co-parents, a chosen family that rejects conventional labels. The eight-years-later epilogue confirms the retreat center exists, Lizzie is loved by both women, Karl remains Lizzie's father but not Eve's partner, and the community they imagined has become real. The final dance circle with Flora in the center is the book's final image of inclusive, chosen joy.

What We Found Instead by Heidi Reimer Book Cover

The ending hits harder if you see how you got there.

The ending of What We Found Instead makes more sense with the full plot.

Read the full plot, chapter by chapter

Where Every Character Ends Up

Eve Moretti: Gives birth to Elizabeth Violet Moretti, called Lizzie, with Maggie's help; she chooses Maggie over Karl, banishes Karl as her partner/co-parent, and co-parents Lizzie with Maggie. Eight years later she helps run the Truth Landing Wilderness Retreat Center and joins Maggie on the balcony before dancing with Lizzie and Flora.
Maggie Dunn: Becomes Mama Maggie and Lizzie's co-parent; she returns to commit to the lodge and retreat center after leaving Daniel. Eight years later she is Eve's friend, business partner, platonic soulmate and co-parent, and is happy for Daniel's new relationship.
Karl Tarvudd: Leaves after Eve chooses Maggie; he remains Lizzie's father. Eight years later he lives in his parents' house, travels occasionally with Vital Adventures, has Lizzie on weekends, is protective of her, has a new girlfriend, and plans a daddy-daughter Peru trip for Lizzie's ninth birthday.
Lizzie (Elizabeth Violet Moretti): Is born healthy in Maggie's lodge room. Eight years later she is an exuberant, dancing girl who cuts her toe barefoot, surprises her moms with a song, and pulls Maggie and Eve into the dance circle.
Flora: Survives her broken leg from the ice-storm injury. Eight years later she is grey around the eyes and mouth, moves slowly, follows Eve onto the balcony, and is placed in the center of the final dance circle.
Daniel: Reconciles with Eve before Lizzie's birth and gives a toast at the retreat center's fifth-anniversary party. He has a new girlfriend whom Maggie likes, and he is proud of Eve and Maggie.
Charmaine: Remains Maggie's friend. At the anniversary party she dances with Daniel and Lizzie.
Abby: Arrives with the paramedics during the birth, clamps the cord, examines Eve and Lizzie, and confirms Eve's tear is small and needs no stitches.

Questions the Book Leaves Open

  • Whether Karl's new girlfriend lasts, especially after she is miffed about his strictly daddy-daughter Peru trip with Lizzie.
  • Whether Daniel's new relationship lasts and how he continues to grieve Violet while moving forward.
  • Whether Maggie's parents actually move to Still Lake for retirement.
  • Whether Karl fully reckons with the ectopic pregnancy and his treatment of Maggie; the final chapter does not show that conversation.
  • The exact definition of Eve and Maggie's relationship is deliberately left undefined: they reject conventional labels and call themselves platonic soulmates and co-parents.

These are answered in the chapter summary. See the full plot →

Continue Exploring

Read the full summary of What We Found Instead