The Other Kind of Lion Ending Explained

by Catherine Ryan Hyde

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

If you just finished The Other Kind of Lion and have questions about that ending, you are not alone. This page walks through what literally happens, why the story ends that way, and where each character lands. I will keep the spoilers behind a warning, so you can stop here if you have not finished the novel.

Major spoiler warning: everything below reveals the full ending of The Other Kind of Lion.

The Ending, Explained

Listen

0:000:00

What Happens at the End of The Other Kind of Lion

The provided closing text is a Book Club Questions section rather than a narrative chapter, but it confirms that Shirley's last spoken word is 'Hal' and revisits the novel's key emotional moments. In the narrative closing sequence summarized in the notes, Shirley is living in Cash's home after her stroke. Mary runs into Shirley's room, opens the window for Flora, and fetches Shirley's dark red cardigan. Cash brings the mare Flora to the open window; Shirley asks him to unclip the lead rope, and Flora snuffles and nudges Shirley's hands before withdrawing. Shirley says the mare knows she will be okay and wanted to check in on her. Cash tells Shirley that Hallie and Darcy will arrive around two, but Ellen is not coming because she avoids anything that reminds her of Curtis.

Shirley asks Cash to promise that when she is gone he will find opportunities to miss her in good company. Three nights later Cash sleeps on a cot in Shirley's room; Shirley wakes and finds him sitting up watching the moon. Cash recalls Shirley's old promise that it was possible he would like his life and says he has liked it for a really long time. Shirley sees that the filmy curtain is gone and says 'Hal.' The book-club questions then ask readers what to carry forward from that final page, explicitly identifying 'Hal' as Shirley's last spoken word and returning to questions about cruelty, fairness, moral choice, earning love, and mutual care.

The Ending, Explained

The ending works as emotional closure rather than a plot twist. Shirley's arc begins with her noticing Cash because Phoenix nickers at him, then widens into her feeding him, defending him, and telling him he is 'one of us.' The ending reverses that care: after her stroke, Cash—now Dr. Cash Pierce—finds her, houses her, arranges her therapy, and cares for her. The final sequence pays off the novel's repeated idea of mutual rescue: Shirley caught Cash when he was falling, and Cash catches Shirley in her final decline. His promise to miss her 'in good company' matters because it ensures he will not isolate himself after her death; he has Bernie, the girls, animals, and the old property he bought to recreate the place where, as a boy, he felt everything was okay.

The last word, 'Hal,' ties the ending back to the opening motif. Phoenix first nickered at Cash in a way Shirley associated only with her dead husband, and throughout the book Hal's absence shapes Shirley's grief. Earlier Shirley describes the boundary between the living and the dead as becoming more like a curtain she could reach out and pull back; at the end she sees that filmy curtain is gone and says 'Hal.' The novel leaves the metaphysical meaning open—whether this is literal reunion, hallucination, or subjective comfort—but emotionally it signals acceptance and readiness rather than fear. The Book Club Questions reinforce that the ending is meant to be carried forward as a reflection on fairness, chosen family, and whether love and belonging must be earned.

The Other Kind of Lion by Catherine Ryan Hyde Book Cover

The ending hits harder if you see how you got there.

The ending of The Other Kind of Lion makes more sense with the full plot.

Read the full plot, chapter by chapter

Where Every Character Ends Up

Shirley Bennett: After a hemorrhagic stroke, she lives in Cash's home and receives care from Cash, Bernie, Marie, and her speech therapist. The story leaves her at the moment of death or transition: she wakes, sees the filmy curtain gone, and says 'Hal,' which the closing questions identify as her last spoken word.

Ludlow 'Cash' Pierce: He becomes Dr. Cash Pierce, searches for Shirley for fifteen years, and cares for her after her stroke. He marries Bernie, fathers Mary, adopts Annie, buys Shirley's old property for a retirement farm, and promises Shirley he will miss her in good company after she is gone.

Bernie Cain: She is Shirley's speech-language pathologist and later Cash's wife. She mothers Mary and Annie and remains part of the family around Shirley at the end.

Mary Shirley Pierce-Cain: She is Cash and Bernie's biological daughter, named partly for Shirley. She appears as a child in the household and helps Shirley by opening the window and fetching her cardigan near the end.

Annie: She is Cash and Bernie's adopted daughter. She rides horses, competes in her first show, and is part of the family Shirley watches over in the later chapters.

Curtis Bennett: He dodges the draft and goes to Canada, later marries Ellen, fathers Hallie, and becomes Darcy's grandfather. He dies of cancer; his last word is reported as 'Dad?' spoken like a question.

Reid Bennett: He goes to Vietnam when drafted. The military notification and Shirley's later references to losing Reid indicate that he dies in the war.

Hal: Shirley's husband is dead before the main story begins; he died at twenty-five in Vietnam. He remains a central absence, and Shirley's last spoken word is 'Hal.'

Ellen: She is Curtis's widow and Hallie's mother. After Curtis's death she avoids anything that reminds her of him and does not come to the final family gathering at Cash's house.

Hallie: She is Curtis and Ellen's daughter, Darcy's mother, and Shirley's granddaughter. She visits Shirley near the end and asks her how to get through loss.

Darcy: She is Hallie's young daughter and Shirley's great-granddaughter. She is expected to arrive at Cash's house near the end with Hallie.

Jace: Cash's older half brother raises him, moves them to Pennsylvania for Bethlehem Steel work, and later manages a tire store in Prescott, Arizona.

Phoenix: Hal's old horse and Shirley's horse dies before the later timeline. His ashes and slate plaque remain on Shirley's old property, which Cash buys.

Edsel: Shirley's elderly black lab dies quietly in his sleep in the dog bed at the foot of Shirley's bed.

Flora: Flora is a mare at Cash's farm. Near the end Cash brings her to Shirley's open window, where she snuffles and nudges Shirley's hands before withdrawing.

Stu: Stu is Cash's dog. He appears at breakfast and later in the guesthouse with Cash, settling onto Shirley's bed.

Tig: Shirley's cat of eighteen years dies before her stroke. Shirley buries him near the creek and gives him a eulogy.

Questions the Book Leaves Open

The novel does not narrate the moment after Shirley says 'Hal'; her death and any reunion with Hal are implied rather than shown.
The book leaves the metaphysical question open: whether Shirley's sense of the curtain opening and her saying 'Hal' is literal afterlife, dream, hallucination, or subjective comfort.
Ellen's long-term grief and avoidance remain unresolved; she is still staying away from reminders of Curtis at the end.
Jace's later life beyond managing a tire store in Prescott is only sketched, and the novel does not show whether he reconnects with Shirley or Cash's family.
The final Book Club Questions pose interpretive questions about fairness, moral certainty, earning love, and what to carry forward from Shirley's last word rather than answering them.

These are answered in the chapter summary. See the full plot →

Continue Exploring

Read the full summary of The Other Kind of Lion