Night Calls Characters
by Joe Hart

Night Calls has a large, interconnected cast built around secrets, family, and small-town suspicion. Hattie Conlee anchors the story, with Tommy, Julian, and the Crawfords close by, while figures tied to the Bedfellow case and Eeling's investigation widen the circle.
On this page you'll find each character's role, a short description, and the arcs and relationships that connect them, from Hattie's hidden history to the people caught up in Tommy's past, the Crawford household, and Ross Eeling's book. It keeps the cast easy to sort without losing the tangle.
Main Characters
Hattie Conlee
ProtagonistA guarded woman living under the assumed identity Mary Whittaker in a seaside cottage, where she cares for Julian and hides that she is his biological grandmother. She is Tommy Conlee's mother and Ed's widow, and her constructed calm is threatened by Ross Eeling's blackmail and her history with Tommy. Her protective rituals, daymares, and secret identity shape her actions.
Arc: She moves from secrecy and denial about Tommy toward investigating the Bedfellow case, sheltering Tommy, and trying to exonerate him. She reconnects with Tommy and confronts Colm after his confession; she is shoved off the bank and survives, cradled by Tommy as Colm walks into the sea.
- Julian — her secret biological grandson
- Tommy Conlee — her son
- Ed — her deceased husband
- Wendy Crawford — her neighbor and friend, who knows her as Mary
- Kevin Crawford — her neighbor, who knows her as Mary
- Sloan Ballard — her closest friend and neighbor
- Ross Eeling — the journalist who blackmails her
- Colm Tyring — family friend she confronts after his confession
- Leah Sterling — Tommy's former girlfriend and Julian's biological mother
- Sheriff Harry Altringer — law enforcement officer who questions her
- Dustin Reiten — old friend she suspects and lures into a trap
Colm Tyring
AntagonistTommy's childhood friend and one of the younger people Hattie counts as family; he was abused by his mother Brenda and left alone with her body. He appears supportive and helps Hattie and Tommy plan the trap, but is revealed as the Bedfellow killer. He says his dead mother made him do it and that Hattie helped him stop after Paige.
Arc: He joins Hattie's investigation and helps confront Dustin, then in the final chapter confesses after Hattie's remark about the observatory video. He shoves Hattie off the bank and walks into the bay, disappearing underwater.
- Tommy Conlee — his childhood friend
- Hattie Conlee — family friend he says helped him stop
- Dustin Reiten — friend he speaks bitterly of
- Brenda Tyring — his abusive mother
- Jolette Smith — his relative
- Gemma — his girlfriend of about four months
- Leah Sterling — friend
Dustin Reiten
AntagonistTommy's former best friend and Leah's partner, who as a teen committed break-ins after his sister Alicia's death. He threatens Eeling, lies about seeing Tommy enter Cheryl's place, and is suspected of framing Tommy. Evidence later ties items in his garage to murders.
Arc: He confesses under Hattie's recording that he lied, fights Tommy, shoots Tommy with Sloan's pistol, and is killed by Colm.
- Tommy Conlee — his former best friend whom he lied about
- Leah Sterling — his partner
- Hattie Conlee — old friend he confronts
- Ross Eeling — threatened him at a hotel
- Alicia Reiten — his older sister
- Colm Tyring — friend
Ross Eeling
AntagonistA journalist and blackmailer writing a book about Tommy and the Bedfellow case. He discovers Hattie's identity as Mary Whittaker and pressures her, Leah, Dustin, and Colm for information. He claims his project will prove Tommy innocent and records interviews and memos.
Arc: He is found dead in bed with a zip-tied plastic bag over his head, apparently suicide; Hattie doubts it and later learns his files and recordings point toward Tommy's innocence and Dustin's threat.
- Hattie Conlee — blackmailer and interviewer
- Tommy Conlee — subject of his book and investigation
- Leah Sterling — blackmailed her for information
- Dustin Reiten — blackmailed him and was threatened by him
- Colm Tyring — threatened him to get information
- Natalie Eeling — his separated wife
- Sheriff Harry Altringer — investigates his death
Supporting Characters
Tommy Conlee
SupportingHattie's son and Julian's biological father, convicted of the Bedfellow murders and later escaped from custody. He hides in Hattie's house and explains his years on the run, insisting he blacked out and may have been framed. He is battered, despairing, and at times violent, but wants to reconnect with Hattie and reclaim his life.
Arc: He reconnects with Hattie, helps investigate the evidence, and confronts Dustin; after Dustin shoots him, he is hospitalized, arrested, then released on bail after evidence points to Dustin. He is exonerated through a state settlement and cradles Hattie after Colm shoves her.
- Hattie Conlee — his mother
- Julian — his biological son
- Ed — his father
- Leah Sterling — his former girlfriend and Julian's biological mother
- Dustin Reiten — his former best friend who lied about him
- Colm Tyring — his childhood friend, whom he suspected and who says it was never supposed to be Tommy
- Sloan Ballard — friend he wanted to see before intending to die
Julian
SupportingHattie's secret biological grandson, adopted by Wendy and Kevin Crawford; he is quiet and opens up to Hattie. He is bullied by Bastion and later stabs him with scissors, and he admits to anger and self-harm. Hattie fears he may share traits with Tommy.
Arc: He moves from a withdrawn boy to a child in legal and therapeutic trouble. By the end he calls Hattie 'Grandma' and talks quietly with Tommy.
- Hattie Conlee — his biological grandmother
- Wendy Crawford — his adoptive mother
- Kevin Crawford — his adoptive father
- Tommy Conlee — his biological father
- Leah Sterling — his biological mother
- Bastion Graner — his bully
Wendy Crawford
SupportingJulian's adoptive mother and Hattie's neighbor, who knows Hattie as Mary. She is concerned about Julian after bullying and stabbing incidents, and she trusts Hattie with him. She later feels betrayed when she sees Hattie's investigation notes.
Arc: She confronts Hattie over the notes, but by the final chapter she hosts a family lunch and reconciles with Hattie, rebuilding trust.
- Julian — her adoptive son
- Kevin Crawford — her husband
- Hattie Conlee — neighbor and friend
- Bastion Graner — the boy her son stabbed
Kevin Crawford
SupportingJulian's adoptive father and Wendy's husband, who knows Hattie as Mary. He initially rebuffs Hattie's concerns about Julian and later texts her to stay away from his family. He advocates for Julian to return home after the stabbing and handles legal and therapy matters.
Arc: He remains protective of Julian and wary of Hattie through the investigation, but by the final chapter he is at the Crawford lunch and asks about Tommy's settlement.
- Julian — his adoptive son
- Wendy Crawford — his wife
- Hattie Conlee — neighbor, whom he tells to stay away
Sloan Ballard
SupportingHattie's elderly closest friend and neighbor across the cove, whom she brings groceries and clotted cream. He is lonely, kind, and has lost his son Nicholas. He reveals he knew about Hattie's swapped cream and tells her she can talk to him.
Arc: He suffers a heart attack and undergoes surgery, later comes to Hattie's aid with a pistol during the confrontation with Dustin, and in the final chapter arrives with a cane and pie after a second heart attack.
- Hattie Conlee — best friend and neighbor
- Adam — his son
- Nicholas (Nicky) — his drowned son
Ed
SupportingHattie's deceased husband and Tommy's father, remembered through memories of French toast, his shop, and a custom teeter-totter for Tommy. He believed Tommy's arrest was a mistake at first, later accepted Tommy's guilt sooner than Hattie, and opposed adopting Leah's baby. He dies in an October 2018 flashback beside his table saw after fighting with Hattie.
Arc: His death and last words haunt Hattie, and his revolver is used in the final confrontation.
- Hattie Conlee — his wife
- Tommy Conlee — his son
- Billy Wescot — his childhood friend and lawyer
Leah Sterling
SupportingTommy's former girlfriend and Julian's biological mother, who has known Hattie for years. She is blackmailed by Eeling and later becomes Dustin's partner. She gives Julian up for adoption and goes into hiding after Tommy's escape.
Arc: She reconnects with Hattie at Thanksgiving, shows her letters and photos of Julian, and by the final chapter arrives with Tommy and plays with Julian; Dustin's death has aged her.
- Tommy Conlee — her ex-boyfriend and Julian's father
- Julian — her biological son
- Dustin Reiten — her partner
- Hattie Conlee — close friend
- Colm Tyring — friend
Sheriff Harry Altringer
SupportingA county sheriff who investigates Ross Eeling's death and questions Hattie as Mary Whittaker. He probes her California identity and why she moved to the area, and he senses that people can hide their true selves. He leaves a card asking her to call.
Arc: He remains suspicious of Hattie's identity but does not uncover her secret in the notes; his investigation connects Eeling's death to Hattie.
- Hattie Conlee — questions her as Mary Whittaker
- Ross Eeling — investigates his death
- Mindy Mason — local who gave him information
Detective Ramsby
SupportingThe detective who questioned Hattie and Ed after Tommy's arrest and later dismissed Hattie's reports of silent calls as a crank. In Eeling's recordings, he admits withholding a hair found on Whitney Moorhead's bed and says he has a spot of doubt about Tommy's guilt. Hattie later learns Ramsby died shortly before she hears the recording.
Arc: His recorded admission raises doubt about Tommy's conviction and helps lead to Tommy's exoneration.
- Tommy Conlee — investigator of his case
- Hattie Conlee — questioned her and Ed
- Ross Eeling — recorded interviewee
- Whitney Moorhead — investigated her case
Natalie Eeling
SupportingRoss Eeling's separated wife and mother of Owen. She initially says she threw Eeling's work away, then recognizes Hattie as 'the mother' and lets her search his laptop and mail. She is grieving and ambivalent about his work.
Arc: She allows Hattie access to Eeling's materials, which leads Hattie to the manila envelope from D. Ramsby.
- Ross Eeling — her separated husband
- Hattie Conlee — lets her search Eeling's materials
Adam
SupportingSloan's son, who calls Hattie about Sloan's heart attack and meets her at the hospital. He recounts that his mother left after his brother Nick drowned and that Sloan never blamed him.
Arc: He remains a worried son and provides family backstory for Sloan's grief.
- Sloan Ballard — his father
- Nicholas (Nicky) — his brother who drowned
- Hattie Conlee — acquaintance he calls Mary
Gemma
SupportingColm's girlfriend of about four months, who meets Hattie at the Crawford lunch and talks about teaching and meeting Colm through his astronomy program. She shows a video of the equatorial room demonstration that helps Hattie recognize the observatory sound.
Arc: She appears briefly at the final gathering and inadvertently provides the clue that exposes Colm.
- Colm Tyring — her boyfriend
- Hattie Conlee — meets her at the gathering
Mindy Mason
SupportingA cashier at Haven's Market who chatters and asks Hattie personal questions; she knows Hattie as Mary. She later tells Sheriff Altringer she saw Eeling at the market coffee bar and his rental car at Hattie's place. Her observations connect Eeling to Hattie and help prompt Altringer's questioning.
Arc: She remains a minor local figure whose information increases suspicion around Hattie.
- Hattie Conlee — cashier and acquaintance
- Sheriff Harry Altringer — gave him information about Eeling
- Ross Eeling — saw him and his rental car
Billy Wescot
SupportingEd's childhood friend and the Conlees' lawyer, who goes to Harrisburg to try to get Tommy released and later explains the evidence against Tommy. He advises Hattie and Ed not to speak to the press or police. He represents Tommy and becomes the family's legal anchor during the arrest.
Arc: He does not appear after the early chapters, but his legal intervention shapes the family's response to Tommy's arrest.
- Ed — his childhood friend
- Tommy Conlee — his attorney
- Hattie Conlee — longtime friend
Cheryl Barton
SupportingTommy's former girlfriend who is found stabbed to death; she had a public fight with Tommy. Ginger Beckem says Cheryl confronted Leah at Pizza Train and threatened to kill her. Her murder is initially treated as a Bedfellow killing and becomes evidence against Tommy, though later investigation suggests she was a decoy.
Arc: Her death drives much of the case against Tommy and is later reinterpreted in light of the Bedfellow investigation.
- Tommy Conlee — his former girlfriend
- Leah Sterling — rival who was threatened by her
- Ginger Beckem — coworker who witnessed her confrontation with Leah
Paige McMahon
SupportingTommy's only known victim since his escape eight years earlier; she was killed in her sleep five years before the present. Her murder is tied to an engine seal pick found in Dustin's garage. Her case is central to linking Dustin to the crimes and to Hattie's fear for Julian.
Arc: Her case helps shift suspicion from Tommy to Dustin and supports Tommy's exoneration.
- Tommy Conlee — his victim
- Dustin Reiten — evidence from her murder was found in his garage
Whitney Moorhead
SupportingThe Bedfellow's first victim, a nurse from Lancaster whose death broke her older brother. A hair found on her bed was withheld by Ramsby. The withheld hair and Ramsby's doubt become evidence raising questions about Tommy's conviction, and a hair tie from her case is later found in Dustin's garage.
Arc: Her case is reopened through Ramsby's recorded admission and the evidence found in Dustin's garage.
- Detective Ramsby — investigator of her case
- Dustin Reiten — evidence from her case was found in his garage
Bastion Graner
SupportingJulian's classmate and bully, who follows Julian into a bathroom and tries to shove his head into a toilet. Julian stabs him in the thigh and shoulder with teacher's scissors; he is hospitalized but will be okay. His attack on Julian triggers the stabbing and legal fallout.
Arc: His parents plan to press charges, though the lawsuit is later dropped.
- Julian — his bully and the boy who stabbed him
- Wendy Crawford — she reports his attack on Julian
Jolette Smith
SupportingBrenda Tyring's cousin, who in Eeling's recorded interview describes Brenda's drug abuse, Colm's abuse, her call to social services, and Colm being left alone with Brenda's body. She carries shame for not intervening more when Colm was a child. Her testimony supplies Colm's traumatic background and motive.
Arc: Her interview deepens the understanding of Colm's past and the violence that follows.
- Brenda Tyring — her cousin
- Colm Tyring — her second cousin/relative
- Ross Eeling — recorded interviewee
Brenda Tyring
SupportingColm's mother, whose drug addiction drives her to abuse him and threaten Jolette after social services remove him. She dies of an overdose, leaving Colm alone with her body for days. Her abuse and death shape Colm; he says his dead mother made him do what he did.
Arc: She does not appear in the present; her actions and death explain Colm's trauma and motive.
- Colm Tyring — her son
- Jolette Smith — her cousin
Alicia Reiten
SupportingDustin's older sister, who left home at eighteen, became addicted to alcohol and drugs, and died by jumping from a Chicago balcony. Jane Everson believes Dustin's teen break-ins were seeking comfort after her death. Her death provides context for Dustin's behavior and instability.
Arc: She does not appear in the present; her loss shadows Dustin's history.
- Dustin Reiten — her younger brother
Jane Everson
SupportingAn elderly woman interviewed by Eeling who recounts neighborhood break-ins and finding Dustin Reiten sleeping in her bed after returning early from Seattle. She believes he was seeking comfort after his sister Alicia's death. Her interview provides evidence about Dustin's past and possible instability.
Arc: Her testimony helps Hattie see Dustin as a possible suspect.
- Dustin Reiten — neighbor whose house he broke into
- Ross Eeling — recorded interviewee
Ginger Beckem
SupportingA coworker of Leah at Pizza Train, interviewed by Eeling, who describes overhearing Cheryl threaten to kill Leah and says Leah was in love with Tommy. She says she has nothing to hide. Her interview establishes tension between Cheryl and Leah and supports the case around Tommy.
Arc: Her account helps reconstruct the relationships around Cheryl's murder.
- Leah Sterling — coworker at Pizza Train
- Cheryl Barton — witnessed her confrontation with Leah
- Tommy Conlee — met him once at a party
Nicholas (Nicky)
SupportingSloan's son who drowned; his name appears on stored boxes, and both Sloan and Adam refer to the loss. Sloan's grief over Nick shapes his loneliness and family history. He does not appear in present events; his absence haunts Sloan and Adam.
Arc: His death remains a source of grief for Sloan and Adam.
- Sloan Ballard — his father
- Adam — his brother