Good Writing Key Takeaways

by Allen, Neal

Good Writing by Allen, Neal Book Cover

5 Main Takeaways from Good Writing

Replace weak verbs with vivid, precise actions

Instead of saying 'he was tired,' say 'he collapsed into the chair.' Strong verbs do the heavy lifting of showing and telling, eliminating the need for adverbs and flabby constructions. The book's first rule—'Use Strong Verbs'—is the foundation for energetic, clear prose that lets readers see the action without explanation.

Trust your reader to fill in the gaps

Cut unnecessary transitions ('then,' 'actually'), filter words ('he thought,' 'she felt'), and redundant explanations. Readers naturally infer sequence, emotion, and backstory when you give them vivid, specific details. Clarity doesn't mean over-explaining—it means providing just enough to spark their imagination, then getting out of the way.

Master the music of your sentences

Vary sentence length, place the strongest word at the end, and use the rule of three for rhythm. Read your work aloud to catch flat spots. The book teaches that every sentence is a miniature composition—long flows need payoffs, short lines need impact, and semicolons can link cousin thoughts without a heavy transition.

Kill your crutches and trim the fat

Delete 'very,' 'really,' 'just,' 'important,' and strings of tiny prepositions. Replace 'of' chains with possessives, and cut any word that doesn't earn its place. A single revision pass focused on these empty fillers can transform flat prose into something tight, clear, and powerful—like cleaning a cluttered room.

Finish the damn thing, then polish with an editor

The only rule you can't break is to complete your draft. Perfectionism is the enemy; a bad finished draft is better than an abandoned one. Once done, worship a talented editor who sees your blind spots. The book's final chapters remind you that writing is both destructive and generative—start badly, revise deeply, and let collaboration refine your voice.

Executive Analysis

These five takeaways form a single, coherent philosophy: good writing is invisible. It serves the story or idea by using strong verbs, trusting the reader, crafting rhythm, cutting clutter, and finishing. Allen and Neal argue that rules are not constraints but tools—each designed to remove the distance between the reader's mind and the writer's intention. The central thesis is that simplicity, precision, and authenticity beat flashy style every time. From replacing 'was' with a vivid verb to dropping 'actually' and layering sentences, every rule points toward the same goal: absorption, not admiration.

This book matters because it offers a practical, rule-based system that works for both fiction and nonfiction. Unlike many writing guides that preach vague principles, 'Good Writing' gives you a checklist of 36 concrete rules you can apply immediately. It sits in the tradition of Strunk & White and Stephen King's 'On Writing' but updates the advice for modern readers—focusing on voice, trust, and the psychological reality that writing is hard on purpose. For anyone who wants to write clearer, more compelling prose, this is a masterclass in doing less to say more.

Chapter-by-Chapter Key Takeaways

Rule 1: Use Strong Verbs (Chapter 1)

  • Strong verbs replace weak, imprecise ones to add energy and clarity.

  • A vivid verb can reshape your sentence structure, breaking monotony.

  • Specific verbs eliminate the need for most adverbs.

  • Avoid the trap of over-glorifying action; don't make every victory a massacre.

  • The best verbs are precise enough that the reader sees the action without explanation.

Try this: Replace every weak verb in your draft with a precise, vivid one that lets readers see the action without explanation.

Rule 2: Question “Being” and “Having” (Chapter 2)

  • “To be” and “to have” freeze a sentence in place; they signal identity or possession, not action.

  • Replace them with verbs that show process, change, or sensory detail whenever possible.

  • Exceptions: auxiliary uses (particularly for progressive tense) and authoritative declarative statements.

  • Challenge yourself to spot every instance of these “barely verbs” during revision—and transform them into language that moves.

Try this: During revision, search for 'is,' 'was,' 'are,' 'have,' and 'had' and replace each with a verb that shows process or sensory detail.

Rule 3: Keep It Active (Chapter 3)

  • Favor active voice, but recognize that passive voice can be superior for emphasis, dramatic effect, or wry tone.

  • Watch for -ed, -en, and -ing endings that may flatten your prose; ask whether flipping the sentence would add energy.

  • Trust your ear, but use the rule as a pointer: if you spot a passive construction, consider whether the object of the sentence deserves the spotlight.

  • Passive works when you want to center the recipient of an action (victims, the universe) rather than the doer.

  • -ing verbs, while not technically passive, often create distance or a singsong rhythm; tightening them can increase tension and immediacy.

Try this: Flag every passive construction and ask whether the object deserves the spotlight; if not, flip to active voice to add energy.

Rule 4: Stick with “Said” (Chapter 4)

  • “Said” is a functional word; readers register who spoke, not the verb itself.

  • Synonyms like “claimed” or “argued” introduce author bias—use them deliberately, not as fillers.

  • Avoid adverbs after attributions; let the dialogue show the tone.

  • Reserve colorful attributions (“whispered,” “mumbled”) for moments where they add real meaning.

  • A long stretch of “said” is okay; a desperate synonym is worse.

Try this: Use 'said' as your default attribution and let dialogue carry tone—save colorful verbs or adverbs only when they add real meaning.

Rule 6: Prefer Anglo-Saxon Words (Chapter 5)

  • Choose Anglo-Saxon words over Latinate ones when possible: “crash” over “collision,” “hurl” over “propel,” “smelly” over “malodorous.”

  • Concrete, physical language engages the body and emotions, not just the intellect.

  • Avoid political or academic jargon that distances the reader.

  • Borges’ trick: when two synonyms exist, pick the one that feels more immediate for the sentence.

  • Never use a word that forces a reader to stop and look it up—unless the payoff is worth the pause.

Try this: Swap Latinate words for Anglo-Saxon ones (e.g., 'crash' instead of 'collision') to make language physical and emotionally immediate.

Rule 7: Sound Natural (Chapter 6)

  • Formal, literary language creates distance between the reader and the story—trust is better built with conversational, natural speech.

  • Use a code like "maybe a bit much?" to catch when you're slipping into flamboyant or stiff phrasing.

  • Exceptions exist (historical fiction, political speeches) but they require deliberate choice, not default.

  • Character-driven narration demands voice consistency—formal abstraction kills individual personality.

  • The writer's goal is absorption, not admiration; let the story carry the weight, not the style.

Try this: Read your draft aloud and mark any phrase that sounds stiff or flamboyant with 'maybe a bit much?' then rewrite it conversationally.

Rule 8: Trust Your Voice (Chapter 7)

  • Your writing voice is discovered, not invented—stop imitating and start riffing.

  • Identify your dominant musical element (melody, rhythm, or harmony) and lean into it.

  • Don’t force metaphors or styles that aren’t yours; an imperfect attempt is worse than none.

  • Read your work aloud to test rhythm and flow—commas and pauses are your tools.

  • Embrace your quirks; they’re what make your voice unique and worth reading.

Try this: Identify whether your natural writing leans toward melody, rhythm, or harmony, then lean into that strength instead of imitating others.

Rule 9: Question Transitions (Chapter 8)

  • Eliminate “then,” “when,” “meanwhile,” and similar transitions unless a genuine gap in time or logic exists.

  • Readers infer sequence and causality naturally—don’t overexplain.

  • Replace abstract time markers with vivid, concrete changes (weather, growth, objects, seasons).

  • Delete every instance of “actually.” It’s a meaningless verbal tic.

  • Test every transitional phrase: does the story’s momentum already carry the reader? If yes, cut it.

Try this: Delete every 'then,' 'when,' 'meanwhile,' and 'actually' unless a genuine time gap exists; let momentum carry the reader.

Rule 10: Link Ideas with Semicolons (Chapter 9)

  • Use semicolons to link two complete, closely related sentences where one logically follows or complements the other.

  • The semicolon creates a “sliding pause” that reinforces connection without a transitional word.

  • It works best when the two sentences are “cousin thoughts”—related but each complete on its own.

  • You don’t have to use semicolons if they feel unnatural, but don’t avoid them out of grammatical snobbery.

  • Writing is about creating a vivid, continuous dream for the reader; flexible grammar can serve that goal.

Try this: Use a semicolon between two complete, closely related sentences where one logically follows the other to reinforce connection without a transition word.

Rule 11: Drop “Very” and Other Crutch Words (Chapter 10)

  • Delete “very” and similar crutch words like “really,” “basically,” “some,” and “important.” They weaken, not strengthen.

  • Replace with precise, vivid words when the base word isn’t strong enough (e.g., “exhausted” not “very tired”).

  • Use the “damn” trick from William Allen White to break the habit.

  • Beware of “important” —it’s often just “important to me” and loses authority.

  • Do a word search on your first draft to strip out nearly every “very.” The exceptions are rare and usually not worth keeping.

Try this: Search your draft for 'very,' 'really,' 'basically,' and 'important' and replace each with a single precise word or delete it entirely.

Rule 12: Jettison [All Those] Tiny Words (Chapter 11)

  • Look for strings of short words (prepositions, pronouns, connectors) and ask if each one earns its place.

  • Replace "of" chains with possessives when possible.

  • Eliminate redundant qualifiers and empty synonyms like "in order to."

  • Be suspicious of conversational padding like "meet up with" or "as a matter of fact."

  • Treat your sentences like a room: uncram them until they feel light and clear.

Try this: Cut strings of short prepositions and pronouns—replace 'of the' chains with possessives and remove empty phrases like 'in order to.'

Rule 13: Dress up “This” (Chapter 12)

  • Adorn "this" with a noun immediately after it to avoid ambiguity (e.g., not "This was hard," but "This puzzle was hard").

  • Apply the same rule to "it" and other pronouns when their referent isn't painfully obvious.

  • Great writers can break the rule (Austen, Orwell) by creating suspense with a delayed referent, but most of us should default to clarity.

  • Ask "This what?" or "Which it?" as a habit—it often leads to a more vivid, specific sentence.

  • Overusing "just" is a similar lazy crutch; cut it when you can.

  • The ultimate goal: keep readers reading, not decoding.

Try this: Adorn every 'this' with a noun immediately after (e.g., 'this puzzle') to eliminate ambiguity; apply the same test to 'it' and 'just.'

Rule 14: Remove the Boring Stuff (Chapter 13)

  • Remove excess logical explanation; your reader can fill many gaps.

  • Use hinting, foreshadowing, and misdirection instead of telegraphing.

  • Skipping the middle term of a logical argument (enthymeme) is often fine.

  • Cut at least a third of your descriptions and editorializing.

  • In nonfiction, consider cutting lies that don’t serve the truth—except a few you can’t bear to part with.

Try this: Remove excess logical explanations, telegraphing, and at least a third of your descriptions; let readers fill gaps with hinting and misdirection.

Rule 15: Refresh Your Words (Chapter 14)

  • Avoid repeating distinctive words quickly; let novelty linger.

  • Use bridging (intentional repetition) for rhythm and hypnosis.

  • Overused or pretentious words ("bloom," "liminal") usually backfire.

  • Always have a fresh pair of eyes catch your unconscious repeats.

Try this: During revision, circle any repeated distinctive words and replace the second instance with a fresh synonym or restructure the sentence.

Rule 16: Know Your Words inside and Out (Chapter 15)

  • Etymology makes abstract concepts tangible; knowing that “truth” means “tree” can generate fresh imagery.

  • Three near-synonyms for a desired state—satisfaction, equanimity, contentment—reveal distinct physical origins (fullness, breath, expansiveness) that can inspire character work.

  • The word “writing” originated as “carving” or “tearing,” and “create” as “to grow”—a reminder that writing is both destructive and generative.

  • Investigating a word’s history can reframe personal struggles or open new creative paths, as Abigail Thomas’s discovery about “acceptance” shows.

Try this: Look up the etymology of one abstract word in your draft to unlock concrete imagery and fresh character insights.

Rule 17: Stay in Tune (Chapter 16)

  • The perfect word is both precise and unnoticeable; if it draws attention to itself, it’s wrong.

  • Use a thesaurus to find the right common word, not to dig up obscure ones that will make you sound pretentious.

  • One wrong word can destroy reader trust—test your choices with the same sensitivity you’d use in conversation.

  • When you can’t find the word, change the sentence structure rather than stretch a synonym.

  • Personal voice matters: the right word for you might not be the right word for someone else, and sometimes you have to fight for it.

Try this: Test every word with the sensitivity of conversation—if it draws attention to itself, change the sentence structure instead of stretching a synonym.

Rule 18: Find the Hidden Metaphor (Chapter 17)

  • Metaphor is not just a literary device but a fundamental mode of thinking and speaking.

  • Strong verbs often carry their own hidden metaphors; use them instead of forcing explicit comparisons.

  • Bad metaphors stick out and undermine the sentence; test every one for naturalness.

  • A successful metaphor enhances its environment; a forced one should be removed.

  • The best metaphors feel inevitable, as if the thought could only be expressed that way.

Try this: Examine every strong verb you use; if it doesn't carry a hidden metaphor naturally, replace it with one that does.

Rule 19: Twist Clichés (Chapter 18)

  • Use clichés as starting points, not endpoints; twist them to create surprise.

  • A familiar phrase with a small mutation (e.g., “good as brass, barely”) can feel more alive than an entirely original line.

  • Unknown or obscure clichés (like “happy as a sandboy”) can be used as-is because most readers won’t recognize them as clichés.

  • Let first drafts be cliché-filled; they’re scaffolding, not the finished building.

  • The enemy is momentum loss—do whatever it takes to keep writing, even if it means leaning on a tired phrase temporarily.

Try this: Twist a familiar cliché in your next draft (e.g., 'good as brass, barely') to create surprise rather than start from scratch.

Rule 20: Knock Three Times (Chapter 19)

  • The rule of threes satisfies our ear for rhythm, creating a natural sense of completion and emphasis.

  • Two-item lists can be equally powerful, adding suspense or openness where a third would feel too tidy.

  • Read your work aloud to hear the beat; let your voice guide your choice, not a rigid rule.

  • Your voice has quirks—honor them. What works for one writer may not work for another, and that’s the point.

Try this: Read your sentence aloud and if a list of three feels too tidy, cut it to two for suspense; let your voice guide the rhythm.

Rule 21: Stretch Out (Chapter 20)

  • Long sentences need linear momentum, not backtracking curlicues.

  • Every long sentence must deliver a payoff that justifies the ride.

  • Great writers can break the rules, but most of us should aim for clarity and propulsion.

  • The best long sentences feel like a natural stream of thought, not an intellectual stunt.

Try this: When writing a long sentence, ensure linear momentum and a payoff that justifies the ride; avoid backtracking curlicues.

Rule 22: Short Sells (Chapter 21)

  • Use short sentences sparingly but deliberately, like a drum hit or a pause button.

  • Long, flowing prose gains power when it’s bookended by something abrupt.

  • The most profound statements are often the briefest—two words can hold a universe.

  • Short sentences work best when they feel earned, not tricksy. Keep practicing until it feels natural.

Try this: Use a short sentence deliberately as a drum hit—place it after flowing prose to create impact and a pause for the reader.

Rule 23: Give Your Sentence a Finale (Chapter 22)

  • The end of a sentence is its most powerful position; place your strongest word or image there.

  • Push verbs close to the period for immediacy and energy.

  • If the ending can't be strong, make the beginning strong instead.

  • Treat every sentence as a miniature composition: rearrange words until the final beat feels right.

  • Aim for clean, decisive endings—not grandiosity. Precision beats noise every time.

Try this: Rearrange each sentence so the strongest word or image lands at the end, pushing verbs close to the period for immediacy.

Rule 24: Crystallize Your Dialogue (Chapter 23)

  • Dialogue is crystallized thinking: every line should reveal choices, not just personality.

  • Cut hellos, goodbyes, and gossip unless they serve a purpose.

  • Speech patterns must be consistent: introverts, jokers, grunters all have signature starts.

  • Balance dialogue with action and interior monologue to avoid reader fatigue.

  • Use the situation-complication-resolution arc to fuel conflict through conversation.

  • In nonfiction, replace direct quotes with inferential details of reaction.

  • Record your dialogue aloud to catch false notes before sharing.

  • Distinguish characters by age, culture, education, and temperament, not just by name.

  • Study masters of dialogue—in novels and in screenplays—to internalize rhythm and authenticity.

Try this: Cut hellos, goodbyes, and gossip from dialogue; every line should reveal a choice, not just personality—then record it aloud to catch false notes.

Rule 25: In Fiction, Archetype Your Characters (Chapter 24)

  • Archetype your characters below stereotypes to avoid blurring and keep them psychologically consistent.

  • Early drafts produce a “bodyguard” exterior; later drafts reveal the contradictory, hidden interior.

  • Use Jungian systems (Myers-Briggs, enneagram) to map hidden fears, motivations, and behavioral traits.

  • Internal specialness requires attention in every scene, not just a one-line physical description.

  • Write from your own multifaceted self—your characters are aspects of you, and that authenticity draws readers in.

Try this: Map your protagonist's hidden fears using a Jungian system (e.g., enneagram) to reveal contradictory interior traits beyond the initial 'bodyguard' exterior.

Rule 26: Show, Then Tell (Chapter 25)

  • “Show, don’t tell” is not a universal law; start with concrete action, then add commentary.

  • Fitzgerald used telling at the end of Gatsby to transform a story into a moral tragedy.

  • Riffing on abstractions after showing action deepens meaning and mirrors how we think.

  • Telling can be more efficient than showing—use it to skip tedium, give essential info, or create empathy.

  • The only rule is what works for the reader; show, then tell, in whatever rhythm the story demands.

Try this: Start a scene with concrete action (show), then add commentary (tell) to deepen meaning—use telling to skip tedium or build empathy.

Rule 27: Give Them a Hero’s Welcome (Chapter 26)

  • Within the first page of your protagonist’s appearance, have another character offer a compliment or signal of likeability.

  • A likable protagonist is the single most important element of a novel—more than plot, setting, or theme.

  • Readers will forgive terrible mistakes if they enjoy spending time with the character.

  • Flawed characters can be lovable: the trick is to plant an early seed of affection, so readers root for them even when they’re a wreck.

Try this: Introduce your protagonist within the first page by having another character offer a compliment or signal of likeability.

Rule 28: Once Is Enough (Chapter 27)

  • Make your first character description definitive. One concise paragraph should establish appearance and psychological foreshadowing, and then you’re done unless a specific trait becomes plot-critical.

  • Revise that paragraph relentlessly. It carries the weight of first impressions, so every sentence needs to earn its place.

  • Treat every described detail as a clue. Readers will subconsciously expect unusual features to matter later (Chekhov’s gun), so choose them deliberately.

  • Anne’s counterpoint: repetition can be kindness. Especially in complex novels with many characters, subtle reminders of key relationships or backstory help readers. Check with your writing group to find the sweet spot between over-explaining and leaving them lost.

Try this: Write one definitive paragraph for each character's first description, then never repeat physical details unless they become plot-critical.

Rule 29: Smell the Roses (Chapter 28)

  • Sight dominates most early drafts; intentionally add the other four senses.

  • Smell and taste are particularly potent memory triggers—Proust’s madeleine is the classic example.

  • Make a separate revision pass focused only on sensory details to break the visual habit.

  • Physical experiences (touching objects, sniffing the air) can unlock fresh language for your writing.

  • The best sensory writing grounds the reader and sparks imagination at the same time—it “spritzes you awake.”

Try this: During a separate revision pass, add one sensory detail from smell, taste, touch, or sound to every scene where sight currently dominates.

Rule 30: Don’t Filter (Chapter 29)

  • Remove verbs of consciousness (thought, felt, wondered, believed) to make characters less self-aware and the writing more immediate.

  • Direct statements and questions are stronger than filtered reflections; “She is right” beats “He thought she was right.”

  • In dialogue, skip “I think” or “I feel”—let the character’s words stand as action.

  • Exceptions exist for metafiction, memoir, and intentional self-reflection, but use them deliberately and sparingly.

  • Final drafts benefit from a focused pass to cut filtering words, but keep the ones that serve your story’s rhythm and natural voice.

Try this: Remove verbs of consciousness (thought, felt, wondered) from your narrative to make characters less self-aware and the writing more immediate.

Rule 31: Trust Your Reader (Chapter 30)

  • Readers instinctively fill in missing character details, backstory, and emotional traits—use this as a tool, not a crutch.

  • Clichéd shortcuts (like dead parents in a car wreck) signal laziness and strip your story of depth.

  • Trust your reader, but give them something worth building on: specific, evocative details that spark their imagination rather than generic blanks.

Try this: Give readers specific, evocative details that spark their imagination—trust them to fill in backstory and emotion without clichéd shortcuts.

Rule 32: Layer Your Sentences (Chapter 31)

  • Every sentence should serve at least two or three of the eight purposes: meaning, plotting, character, diction, rhythm, harmony, color, and seamlessness.

  • Revision is where layering happens: after writing a sentence, ask if it can be more rhythmic, more sensory, more psychologically astute, or more tightly tied to plot.

  • The difference between ordinary and literary writing isn’t a genre boundary—it’s a choice to make each sentence worth rereading.

  • Even a short personal anecdote can demonstrate the method: start with a strong core sentence, then layer in concrete details, emotional beats, and forward momentum.

Try this: Layer every sentence to serve at least two of eight purposes (meaning, plot, character, diction, rhythm, harmony, color, seamlessness) during revision.

Rule 33: Write the Hard Stuff (Chapter 32)

  • Nothing is off-limits. The subjects that stump you first are exactly the ones worth pursuing.

  • Syntactic failure is a signal. If it’s hard to write, it’s probably worth writing.

  • Simplicity is not a cheat. Obvious truths about human behavior—protecting children, sensing possibility—anchor scenes and make them resonate.

  • Follow your characters into mystery. Whether you write fiction or nonfiction, don’t stop at objective distance; go where the irrational and ineffable lead.

  • Start badly, then refine. A terrible first draft is a necessary step toward capturing the stuff that matters. Talk to non-writer friends for fresh language and perspective.

Try this: Write the scene that scares you; if it's syntactically hard, it's probably worth pursuing—start badly and refine with fresh language from non-writer friends.

Rule 34: Break the Rules (Chapter 33)

  • Master a rule completely before you consider breaking it; understand why it works first.

  • Breaking a rule often means switching to a different legitimate framework (fiction vs. exposition, narrative vs. instruction).

  • Know your audience and purpose—practical writing needs clarity; creative writing needs the texture of consciousness.

  • The one rule you cannot break: do not confuse or lose your reader early on. Clarity and engagement come first.

Try this: Master a rule completely before breaking it, then switch to a different legitimate framework (e.g., narrative vs. exposition) rather than flouting clarity.

Rule 35: Finish the Damn Thing (Chapter 34)

  • Completion is your only job; quality and sales are someone else’s problem until later.

  • The inner critic’s fear of failure is the real obstacle—not your talent or the project’s difficulty.

  • Endings must feel inevitable and gratifying; avoid deus ex machina and rushed resolutions.

  • Finishing a bad draft is better than abandoning it—it weakens perfectionism and clarifies your true vision.

  • Readers want to stay in the company of a trustworthy guide, even if the story is ambiguous.

Try this: Finish your current draft no matter how bad; completion weakens perfectionism and clarifies your true vision for the next revision.

Rule 36: Worship (Talented) Editors (Chapter 35)

  • A talented editor is not a threat but a savior, filling blind spots you can't see and making your strengths consistent.

  • The best editorial relationship is built on mutual trust and a shared vocabulary for what makes sentences work.

  • Untalented editors do more harm than good; invest time to find a serious editor who respects your voice.

  • The rules of good writing are universal and survive changes in media; they apply to speech, podcasts, and all forms of communication.

  • Anne's three-draft method (shitty, tighter, dental) shows how to apply the rules progressively without bogging down in perfectionism early on.

  • Editing is a collaborative, sometimes humbling process, but it yields the deep satisfaction of producing work that is cleaner, richer, and more truthful.

Try this: Find a talented editor who respects your voice, fill your blind spots, and apply the three-draft method (shitty, tighter, dental) to progressively polish your work.

Continue Exploring