Everyone's a Liar Book Club Questions

by Alexandra Ivy

Everyone's a Liar by Alexandra Ivy Book Cover
These questions assume everyone has finished the book and contain spoilers, including the ending.

Everyone's a Liar is a lively book club pick because it pairs a fast mystery with messy family loyalty, questionable choices, and characters who keep changing shape as secrets surface. The questions below invite readers to compare first impressions with later revelations, debate who deserves sympathy, and argue about when trust becomes a mistake.

Use them as written, pick a few for a focused conversation, or let one topic carry the whole meeting. They work best when everyone has finished the book, since several questions ask you to rethink earlier moments in light of new information.

Trust, Suspicion, and Livia's Choices

  1. 1.Livia decides not to call the police after she sees Jacob search her dresser and a stranger confront him, telling Marcel she is not sure a crime was committed. Did you agree with that choice, or should she have reported it sooner?
  2. 2.When Bryce discovers Jacob Pearson does not exist and the facial recognition hit points to ex-cop Larry Sutton, how did that reveal reshape your view of Livia's month-long relationship and the erased security videos?
  3. 3.Livia snoops in Winston's SUV and finds a gas receipt dated last Thursday even though he claims he flew in from Dublin. Was her suspicion of Winston justified, or was she too quick to connect him to the man in her bedroom?
  4. 4.After Winston corners Livia in the storage room, she triggers the faulty alarm, locks him in the closet, and calls 911. Did you agree with her instinctive response, and what did it show about how much she had changed since the opening chapter?
  5. 5.Livia refuses Gerald Durand's request to meet and says she is cutting ties with the past and living in the moment. Did you agree with that decision, or should she have confronted her biological father?

Family Secrets and Power

  1. 6.Helene confesses to locking Livia in the garage loft, leaving Giselle's scarf, and pushing Livia into the empty pool, but claims Adrian told her to stop Livia. How did you judge Helene's responsibility versus her fear and grief over Manny?
  2. 7.Winston reveals he is Livia's half-brother, hired and killed Larry Sutton, and shot out her office window. How does that confession reframe his earlier warning behind the bandstand and his engagement to Celeste?
  3. 8.Adrian holds Livia at gunpoint and admits the family covered up Manny's death, Stella Gates's blackmail, and Giselle's diary. Did the final confrontation make the Benoit family's corruption feel inevitable, or did any character still surprise you?
  4. 9.Giselle's note reading 'Rice. Lake Oaks Park at 2 p.m.' leads to Jonathon Rice and the revelation that she called the FBI before her death. How did that discovery change the meaning of Livia's investigation into her mother?
  5. 10.Livia tells Bryce she does not trust her family to care if she disappears, and Helene warns her that the Willows is toxic and to stay free. How effectively does the Willows setting shape the novel's themes of family control and hidden corruption?
  6. 11.Winston says Adrian forced him to propose to Celeste, and Celeste spends the engagement party posing with a too-wide smile. Did learning that change your sympathy for Celeste, or did her earlier cruelty toward Livia still define her for you?

Danger, Friendship, and Protection

  1. 12.Bryce repeatedly puts herself in danger for Livia, from searching Sutton's office to entering the bayou where she is shot, and later faints into Livia's arms. Did you agree with how far she went as a deputy and friend?
  2. 13.Marcel suggests posting revenge messages about Jacob, handles the office repairs after the shooting, and worries about Livia. How does his friendship affect the novel's darker family plot?

Sympathy, Deception, and Motives

  1. 14.Stella Gates was Livia's nanny, lived in a Benoit-owned Slidell house, may have blackmailed the family, and left a photo of Manny marked 'I know what happened.' Did you see Stella as a victim, an opportunist, or both?
  2. 15.The title Everyone's a Liar fits Jacob/Larry, Winston, Helene, and Adrian, but Livia also lies to Flora and withholds details from Bryce. Which deception did you find most damaging, and did any liar remain sympathetic to you?

Continue Exploring